Broughton & Stanton

Started by rider, August 01, 2012, 06:41:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Combo?

Watson & Suckling
Thompson & Birchal
Murphy & Waters
Murphy & Scotland
Other sugestion using combined total of $886,400

rider

Given Stanton is likely out for a couple of weeks as well, which combo will be best to finish the season. Consider resting as well...

Trades - 3 (before suggested double trade)
Bank - $153,400
Team
Deledio, Carazzo, Godard, Shaw, Broughton, Heppel, S Shaw (Smedts Darley)
Swan, Ablet, Stanton, Boyd, Pendlebury, Mitchel (Gibson, Crozier)
Maric, Jacobs (Longer Stephenson)
Sidebottom, Beams, Chapham, Zorko, Robinson, Whitecross, Martin (Franklin, Murdoch)

Spinking

I've gone Murphy and Scotland. Both premiums, both consistent, Murphy may still get a tag for the next couple of weeks but will rip it up after that.

tbagrocks

Quote from: Spinking on August 01, 2012, 06:42:55 PM
I've gone Murphy and Scotland. Both premiums, both consistent, Murphy may still get a tag for the next couple of weeks but will rip it up after that.
Scotland is a "must" and Murphs ave is superior over three years

rider

Thanks guys appreciate the comments. I like your reasoning as well.

Windigo

Just be careful that murphy will cop the tag with no Judd or Kade.  ;)

slipknot_4

Quote from: Windigo on August 01, 2012, 06:55:15 PM
Just be careful that murphy will cop the tag with no Judd or Kade.  ;)


was reading the news on the afl app today n said simpson was a chance to return this week...

i voted scotand and murphy did this exact trade last night..!!

Affliction

If your playing for league keep in mind carlton play saints in the dt final.

Murphy had a shocker last game against them and was tagged out of the game.

Disco DB

Having a rookie D7 isn't the best and your Fwds are overstocked despite Robbo/Buddy issues, but they will be back v soon. Perhaps hold Standon, even thou he's shower & injured (possibly back soon) he's better than S.Shaw, after Gibbo's output last week he'd be a good fill in (or a Fwd swap if all available). That might sound ok in theory but the options in are only Fisher (I don't mind him, for a punt) plus someone decent - Birch will become affordable next week. So Fisher/Birch/(Stanton/Fwd/Gibbo) might work out better than Scot/D rookie/Murph, you'd have to work it out by average/form.