Is Pav $50k better than Chappy??

[sledgey7]

I have 5 trades and lots of cash and i'm making my last forward upgrade.

alot of people wondring the same thing.

Let's let the public decide.

[upthemaidens]

DT  Chappy,, SC  Pav

[Spinking]

Chappy has looked a bit slow in the past few games though. I still think he will out score Pav. Particularly if Johnson doesn't come up this week.

[DT87]

Chappy is better than Pav, full stop. If they were the same price I'd still go for Chappy. Pav is still pretty good, but I would never pay more than $450k for him this late in the season, regardless of form.

[Nails]

Pav more in form and more consistent, Chappy seems to have slowed down of late...

Chappy also has a run home a LOT harder....

Pavlich plays the Demons in rd 23... could be 200 points right there.

Pavlich for mine.

[upthemaidens]

Pav more in form and more consistent, Chappy seems to have slowed down of late...

Chappy also has a run home a LOT harder....

Pavlich plays the Demons in rd 23... could be 200 points right there.

Pavlich for mine.

thats true freo's run home is soft..  i'll change my mind  go pav

[Nails]

Also last 7 round averages
Pavlich: 109.43
Chapman: 100.71

[aces-high]

Pav in fantastic form but my opinion is

Pav sc
Chappy dt

Chappy is very consistent in dt and i think he is still the better option. He may have a harder run but he plays a more dt friendly role. If pav doesnt get a bag he doesnt score that big. Chappy's tackles and stats always keep him up around the 100 :) get chappy man

[Dudge]

I'm going with Nails on this one. At this minute Pavs in better form, and i worry if Chappy's carrying something

[sledgey7]

it's absoltuely lineball for me.
the run home really makes me think pav is gonna score better for the remainder of the season but it would be very handy to have that $50 sitting there for future upgrades/injury trades.

[sledgey7]

dids, god, carrots, scotland, heppel, yarran, bugg (darley, shaw)

gaj, swan, thompson, pendles. boyd, stanton (smith, gibson)

cox, giles (redden, campbell)

beams, buddy, dusty, Rok, danger, J brown, zorko  (treloar, adams)

going darley to waters this week (keping yarran for bench) and either pav or chappy.

chappy leaves me $120k and pav leaves me $70k

that a big difference

[Dudge]

dids, god, carrots, scotland, heppel, yarran, bugg (darley, shaw)

gaj, swan, thompson, pendles. boyd, stanton (smith, gibson)

cox, giles (redden, campbell)

beams, buddy, dusty, Rok, danger, J brown, zorko  (treloar, adams)

going darley to waters this week (keping yarran for bench) and either pav or chappy.

chappy leaves me $120k and pav leaves me $70k

that a big difference

In a situation like that' you're right, but come 2nd semi-prelim-GF, I don't know. Do u want to see Buddy in you're opponents column

[upthemaidens]

dids, god, carrots, scotland, heppel, yarran, bugg (darley, shaw)

gaj, swan, thompson, pendles. boyd, stanton (smith, gibson)

cox, giles (redden, campbell)

beams, buddy, dusty, Rok, danger, J brown, zorko  (treloar, adams)

going darley to waters this week (keping yarran for bench) and either pav or chappy.

chappy leaves me $120k and pav leaves me $70k

that a big difference

who were you trading out in the fwds?  also think you should move on giles first

[sledgey7]

buddy isn't going anywhere.
johnno brown for the chop.

giles has a BE of 50 and this week i'm playing top side for my spot in the four.
more upside to these two trades and can then do giles next week (my opponent has same ruck combo).

[Bruce McAvaney]

Chappy will drag Geelong into the finals.