Rockliff or Hayes

[Felya]

Eventually will trade both these players but at the moment wanting to trade to Murphy, which should I trade? Or should I keep them both as Rockliff comes up against Richmond and could kill it and Hayes has a decent BE. Opinions please?

[bomdiggity]

Rockliff first if you're planning on trading both

[Spinking]

I'd trade Lenny first.  Rockliff has been a bit underwhelming lately but as you say, he could potentially rip it up against Richmond.  He is also significantly younger which may mean he doesnt tire as much going into the finals.

[Felya]

Is it worth the risk of keeping both for another week and hoping Rockliff doesn't drop too much?

[me]

get rid of rocky unless he's got goldcoast or the giants coming up, as he's got a ceiling of about 80 against basically any other side this year

[pommyadam]

run-ins

Hayes: Collingwood, Melbourne, Geelong, GWS, Carlton
Rockliff: Richmond, Carlton, Adelaide, Port, Bulldogs

i'd keep Hayes personally, but if you think he'll be rested vs GWS, then keep Rocky

[Ajax22]

Keep Hayes, lose Rocky. Also there is zero chance of Hayes being rested, can't afford to when fighting for a spot in the 8.