giles - mcevoy??

[sledgey7]

great game by giles to keep his price but surely he can't do it again with a BE of 118.

Mcevoy is a bit cheaper than roughy or maric and he is very reliable.

ranked 2250 5 trades and $413k left.

playing top team for a spot in the top 4.

[Zombie2.5]

Sure he has a BE of 118?? He did score 118...


And vsing Port this week, they only have Lobbe/Redden/Renouf....

I'm sure he can do it again.... And he'll rise in price so you can side trade him later anyways...

[tbagrocks]

really don't like Macca but thats because I don't rate him as a Ruckman! I would suggest Goldstein? NicNat, or Jon to keep pace with the second best?

[aces-high]

If i was you i'd do it man. Mcevoy is the lone ruckman for the saints and is very consistent. Brogan is coming back for this game against the power i'm pretty sure and this greatly effects giles output. Eliminate the worry of giles scores being effected and up and down and get falcon head mcevoy :) hes good for an 80+ week in week out and scores more consistent 100's.

[sledgey7]

giles BE is 50.

i swear i checked his player profile when i started the thread. mustn't have been updated yet.
he stays for now.

[Spinking]

I did this trade a few weeks back and have been very happy with it. McEvoy is not a particularly good ruckman yet, but he does take a lot of marks around the ground and usually rucks alone.

[sledgey7]

next week i think. let giles fatten a tad.
i just want the reliability of mcevoy.
all this depends on cox coming up for the derby.

[youl_R_FCK]

Did this trade two weeks ago. Went him over Jacobs. Looking good since he didn't play last week

[Alka]

If it's a league game you want to win you might want McEvoys extra points.

McEvoy has a good record against the Pies. Scoring 139 and 97 last year. He also has a great record at the MCG. Plus he's in form.
On the flip-side just because Giles "only" plays Port doesn't guarantee a big score. Griffin only got 69 against them on the weekend, despite leading hit-outs. Giles will do alright, but I wouldn't go in expecting a repeat of last week.