Broughton v Baguley

[shredved]

Pretty simple really. Assuming broughton is back who is a better option as a 7th defender.

[Spinking]

I'd go Baguley, but I don't think you'll have to choose. Thread on here earlier that Brough could be done for the season...

[Artax]

Pretty sure Broughton is dead...mostly

[shredved]

Pretty sure Broughton is dead...mostly

Dead to me anyway

[Zombie2.5]

Broughton to Baguely worth it? (If broughton is out)
Baguely is $150k now, but there's no other options(around Brought's price or rooks on bubble).
I still make $170k that should be sufficient for my last two trades as they shouldn't be major upgrades.

[fertalong]

If you have the trades for final 2 trades then I don't see why not.

[Ajax22]

If Broughton gets back to playing again would rate him over Baguley fairly easily. Gotta wonder if Broughton was carrying some niggles that left him playing an even more defensive role than usual. If he comes back into the team you would have to give him a chance I think, Freo's draw isn't half bad either