Play Giles or Redden?

[Carn]

2 50s in his last 2 for giles.
Redden 95 then dropped back in this week.

[taytehille]

Would back Giles to bounce back - especially against Jolly and Dawes.

[fever]

jolly not even playing. would punt on giles, but it's close cos freo dont exactly have a brilliant ruck division

[Spinking]

I'd go Giles. Redden playing second fiddle to Lobbe. Good chance to get a three quarter time vest.

[Colliwobblers]

jolly being rested as expected wood is good but giles should go half ok against him, redden is a mystery bag, who knows how long he will spend on the field or in the middle, after all he was dropped after a great game....

[CeylonTea]

I'm in a similar boat tossing up between Giles or Jenkins, Have Redden and Jenkins on my bench.

[quinny88]

Giles should play well with no Jolly