Players not to touch

[Tommy]

Rhyce Shaw - he is a Shaw
Heath Shaw - ditto
Nick Maxwell - terrible
Travis Cloke - he is a Cloke.
Jordan McMahon - you don't get points playing for Coburg
Xavier Ellis -overhyped year after year by Monty and co.
Leigh Montagna - If he has another season like that, I'll buy you a farm.
Leon Davis - at just under 600k, is supercoach taking the p*ss?
Jared Brennan - 150 one week, 22 the next. Enuf said.
Andrew Lovett - You don't collect points from you cell in Division H
Brady Rawlings - is a bit on the nose at North.
Cameron Wood- At 400k, and with Jolly and Fraser to ruck, Cameron Wood is worse valued player in SC.
Troy Simmonds - See Jordan McMahon
Alan Didak - sh*t bloke. Take ROK instead. Same player, and you would rather barrack for him.

[Alex7089]

Big call on Joey Montagna there, he is a very good player and started last year at 550k so even though last year was somewhat of a breakout year for him I don't think anyone thinks it was a flash in the pan.

[stoneius]

Montagna will have a good year - but no chance of reaching the heights of 2009.  Can't see Saints winning 20 games this year (happened once in over a hundred years unless I'm mistaken?)

[Kazahkstan]

Nice to see some 'wood bashing. :D

[Alex7089]

Montagna will have a good year - but no chance of reaching the heights of 2009.  Can't see Saints winning 20 games this year (happened once in over a hundred years unless I'm mistaken?)

Actually the saints did it lat year the bombers did it in 2000 the cats won 20 games in 2008 (not in a row) and there are probably others but just recently there are 3 in 10yrs.

[tferrier18]

It's obvious your a carlton supporter, seven players in that list are collingwood (or ex) players, so are you just venting your hatred for collingwood?Because I'm sure everyone can post 6-7 players from every team (inc carlton) that shouldn't be chosen...At least their list would be justified though.Some of your choices are correct though.

For all of those SCer's who don't hate collingwood;

Ryce Shaw - Definitely a good supercoach option, third highest scoring backman last year ? See how he goes with Kennelly but it certainly won't impact him too much, he's fit and gets plenty of the ball.
Nick Maxwell - Averaged 93 or so last year? Excellent defender who puts his body on the line at EVERY contest and one of the best captains in the league (maybe not skill wise, but in terms of leadership definitely).
Heath Shaw - debatable, if he spends more time in the mid then maybe but he hast to learn to handle a tag.

[kyle9600]

Alan Didak maybe a shower bloke doesnt mean hes a bad football player

[stoneius]

i was referring to saints not winning > 20 games in a year in their history (outside last year).  most saints players will drop back a bit this year, apart from maybe riewoldt and goddard.

[CFC 1979]

what about these 2 drop kicks ;

PRESTI

LEIGH "THE SPUD" BROWN ( it only took to the first round of the NAB cup for me to bag him ) ;D

[nas]

Petrenko?

[Sams-Town]

Malceski......

[Kazahkstan]

It's obvious your a carlton supporter, seven players in that list are collingwood (or ex) players

Hmm, I would have thought it was obvious he is a carlton supporter because it says under his name. :P

[tferrier18]

It's obvious your a carlton supporter, seven players in that list are collingwood (or ex) players

Hmm, I would have thought it was obvious he is a carlton supporter because it says under his name. :P

I was implying he's a typical carlton supporter for hating on collingwood's players. I can read and did see his team.

[Kazahkstan]

It's obvious your a carlton supporter, seven players in that list are collingwood (or ex) players

Hmm, I would have thought it was obvious he is a carlton supporter because it says under his name. :P

I was implying he's a typical carlton supporter for hating on collingwood's players. I can read and did see his team.

Carlton aren't the only team that hates Collingwood...  ::)

[Justin Bieber]

Leigh Montagna - If he has another season like that, I'll buy you a farm.

Can't wait for my farm ;D.