Trading out steele?

[pinochio]

thats the other problem :)

beams, roughead, zorko, dangerfield, martin, steele, robbo (murdoch, treloar)

can afford any under 470k, SJ or chappy would be prime candiates but dont really want cats imo, hence id be looking at ppl like ROK, rooey or a very contravertial one in Fyfe :O (just thought of that one, too risky thought i think) also stanley ...

looking at ROK tbh with swans/and him is awesome form!!!


thoughts lahug and the rest of yous :)

[LaHug]

If you could afford Pav, I'd consider that an option. Just too short :(
Whitecross maybe. ROK is good. Even though he's questionable, Goodes is also an option.
Drew Petrie is a good option with how good the Roos are going.

Still, I'd rather hold the trade.

[pinochio]

i get what your saying, too bad im too short on pav...

i really think ill trade, thought not sidey....robbo im thinking??

what you think man?

[owenbond007]

Why the flower would one ranked so high ask for a opinion on a trade. The majority on here wouldnt know right from wrong when it comes to trading.

[LaHug]

You seem particularly keen to trade. Sydney may well have a top 2 spot sewn up by round 23 meaning they could rest ROK (he is old!) which would be a disaster. Still, if they don't rest him, ROK is the best option.
Next I would go Stevie J, Petrie, Goodes, Whitecross in that order.
This is just my opinion... Good luck!

[Tominator]

nah mate I would hold. What if this happens again next week in defence for instance? What if you cop an LTI in the next few weeks and have used all your trades? I reckon you would drop in the rankings further if that happens

Hold him, it'll be short-term pain for long-term gain :)

[disco1992]

This is going to sound stupid but my reasoning is to trade as if you are roughly 600 points behind the leaders and if the car is all your striving for the. It's your only chance... Sink or swim

[pinochio]

hmm, have no idea on what to do :)

will simmer in my mind for the whole day :P

[EZA100]

it depends on how serious his injury is if its more than 1 week then get rid of him if its just this week than cop the donut

[PowerBug]

it depends on how serious his injury is if its more than 1 week then get rid of him if its just this week than cop the donut

Problem with that is we probably won't know how bad the injury is until next week.

[EZA100]

it depends on how serious his injury is if its more than 1 week then get rid of him if its just this week than cop the donut

Problem with that is we probably won't know how bad the injury is until next week.

was wondering what it was, don't have him but was considering getting him have to wait now.

[pinochio]

exactly powerbug.....i trade and i have no other 0's!

ppl have hypes of 0's, could be good???

[EZA100]

exactly powerbug.....i trade and i have no other 0's!

ppl have hypes of 0's, could be good???

if you want to take the risk than do it maybe go for somebody that plays more of a midfield role like wright or johnson.

[PowerBug]

well yes, most teams will be coppig donuts this week, if Redden can survive the cut i won't be (but i don't have sidebottom or Robinson) so the bench cover is really low this week.

I'd be leaning towards holding him still.

[pinochio]

good tips fellas!

all taken into mind!