Hasnt been asked yet...

[jamesalex]

Please vote! Will be a useful poll for many!

Miles- Good Scoring, poor JS?
Couch- Average scoring, good JS?
Baguley- Average scoring, average JS?
Josh Bruce- Decent scoring, not sure on JS?

Thanks.

[Spinking]

Couch is probably the best in terms of JS, but in terms of versatility it's hard to past Baguley. Been hanging out for a def / mid rook since season began!

[JamSainter]

Couch is probably the best in terms of JS, but in terms of versatility it's hard to past Baguley. Been hanging out for a def / mid rook since season began!

But don't get fooled. When Hibberd returns in time for the SC finals Baguley is goneski.
I like Miles, has great scoring potential and was in the top 3 for GWS yesterday.

[MLS]

Surely it is Couch??

Cheaper and DPP with better JS

[blue]

Miles by a mile, been injured, played a good game, you would think he will play out the rest of the year

[jamesalex]

NO love for Bruce?

[The Bomber]

Miles by a mile, been injured, played a good game, you would think he will play out the rest of the year

I rate him the best chance to play out the season and avg 60-70

[fever]

depends on your situation. couch if fwd dpp is important. baguley if back dpp is. if you want scoring then miles, though i would say his JS is unknown, but probably ok, given how tired a few of the gws youngsters have looked.

[Footyrulz]

bruce scored well this week but is a key position player so dont think scoring potential is great. also a big gap between games.

couch looks a good option with DPP and decent JS as well.

miles is scoring well and will continue to do so, i think JS is decent after playing well this week, also he plays for GWS which should help his JS.

baguley will be gone come finals time, JS worst of them all.

in order of JS i would say Couch, Bruce, Miles, baguley while scoring ability is Miles, Couch, Baguley, Bruce.

Miles or Couch is best, depends on how much u need the DPP.

[ubeaut]

So Couch has good JS? Really need a DPP MID.

Wish Miles was DPP he looks great.

[SydneyRox]

Melb season is over, so there is no reason not to give Couch a few extra games, the question mark is what they think of him internally? He spent the first half of the season as an elevated rookie getting 20-30 possesions a game in the magoos but couldnt get a senior debut? Makes me a little cautious, but I think the mid/fwd dpp will mean he gets the nod from me as the final downgrade

[ubeaut]

Melb season is over, so there is no reason not to give Couch a few extra games, the question mark is what they think of him internally? He spent the first half of the season as an elevated rookie getting 20-30 possesions a game in the magoos but couldnt get a senior debut? Makes me a little cautious, but I think the mid/fwd dpp will mean he gets the nod from me as the final downgrade

This was my concern over Couch to begin with. How good can he be if he couldn't crack THAT team? Hopefully it's just because they wanted to make sure he was well and truly AFL ready.