My team bad, My team hood, My team do shower that your team wish it could!

Started by powersuperkents, July 22, 2012, 10:34:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What would you rate my completed team?

10 ;D
9 :D
8 :)
7 :/
6 :[
5 :(

powersuperkents

How does my final team look
Trades left: 0
Cash Left: $3,500

Backs: Deledio, Grimes, Birchall, Goddard, Waters, Carrazzo, Broughton, Sam Shaw, Redpath
Midfield: Swan, Ablett, Watson, Rockliff, Ebert, Scott Selwood, Sam Gibson, Newell (DDP with backs incase of midfield injury)
Rucks: Cox, Goldstein, Jenkins, Campbell
Forwards: Sidebottom, Franklin, Dangerfield, Stanley, Martin, Brent Harvey, Hawkins, Murdoch, Couch

Spinking

Not bad. Cover is pretty weak which may cause you trouble with no trades left. Couple of ok PODs.

I'd say 8, but with no trades probably 6.5 - 7

stew42

Backs: All good until you get to Broughton. Redpath isn't good cover. 8/10
Mids: Quite frankly, poor. Ebert and Scooter Selwood should really be upgraded. A bit meh with your Newell idea. 5.5/10
Rucks: Good, but I might be worried when HMac comes back. 8.5/10
Fwds: Quite good, but there are better options than Boomer Harvey and Hawkins. 8/10

Overall, 7.5/10

powersuperkents

Quote from: stew42 on July 25, 2012, 03:58:03 PM
Backs: All good until you get to Broughton. Redpath isn't good cover. 8/10
Mids: Quite frankly, poor. Ebert and Scooter Selwood should really be upgraded. A bit meh with your Newell idea. 5.5/10
Rucks: Good, but I might be worried when HMac comes back. 8.5/10
Fwds: Quite good, but there are better options than Boomer Harvey and Hawkins. 8/10

Overall, 7.5/10
Haha cheers for the honesty, it helps me more :) I can still reverse the Goldstein trade back to Giles and the Grimes trade back to Spurr.

Do you think Bellchambers would make a better ruck than Giles?
or should I take a cheaper option then Grimes (or wait for Spurr's price to rise) and get a ruck like McEvoy in?   

stew42

Haha no problem mate, I will admit, I was feeling a bit mad at the time about a completely unrelated thing, so I might have taken it out a bit on you!

With Grimes, I am suddenly reminded of Higgins' season. Plays all games, averages well enough, people start saying "Wow, this guy is more dependable than Goodes!" (noone actually said that, I made it up. But you get my drift). Nek minut, he's gone. Regardless of what he's done this season, I still consider Grimes as injury prone. But hey, weigh up the odds. I could be wrong...

Goldstein has been doing well, but as I said, HMac will take some of his scores when he comes back week after next. A huge smokey could be NicNat. Averaging 83 alongside Cox, that's not too bad at all.

Bellchambers is in a similar situation to Goldstein, been doing well, but scores will suffer when Ryder comes back. He'll get games (Hille might get the cut), but don't expect brilliance.

Would it be at all possible to bring in Pendles or MMurphy into your mids?

Hope all this helps :)

powersuperkents

Quote from: stew42 on July 25, 2012, 11:53:58 PM
Haha no problem mate, I will admit, I was feeling a bit mad at the time about a completely unrelated thing, so I might have taken it out a bit on you!

With Grimes, I am suddenly reminded of Higgins' season. Plays all games, averages well enough, people start saying "Wow, this guy is more dependable than Goodes!" (noone actually said that, I made it up. But you get my drift). Nek minut, he's gone. Regardless of what he's done this season, I still consider Grimes as injury prone. But hey, weigh up the odds. I could be wrong...

Goldstein has been doing well, but as I said, HMac will take some of his scores when he comes back week after next. A huge smokey could be NicNat. Averaging 83 alongside Cox, that's not too bad at all.

Bellchambers is in a similar situation to Goldstein, been doing well, but scores will suffer when Ryder comes back. He'll get games (Hille might get the cut), but don't expect brilliance.

Would it be at all possible to bring in Pendles or MMurphy into your mids?

Hope all this helps :)
I could upgrade Scott Selwood to Pendles or downgrade Scott Selwood to MMurphy :) but that leaves me with one trade