Asian 15'S RULES AND SET UP DISCUSSION

[PowerBug]

I team per country, and we get the Hong Kong Dongs.
What can we bribe you Spinking?

[Adamant]

If you guys want 1 team per country then I can always go with the 'Bangladesh Bears'.

[Colliwobblers]

yeah i think one team per country is a must

[Adamant]

ok, my team will be called the 'Bangladesh Bears' with Shihan7 as my assistant.

[Colliwobblers]

ok, my team will be called the 'Bangladesh Bears' with Shihan7 as my assistant.

done and done

[Spinking]

I team per country, and we get the Hong Kong Dongs.
What can we bribe you Spinking?

If you guys are really keen for Hong Kong I can hand it over. Sure I can come up with something better... :)

[Colliwobblers]

i like the name hong kong dongs.... i have concerns over the "potential" logo and mascot however  :o

[tbagrocks]

i like the name hong kong dongs.... i have concerns over the "potential" logo and mascot however  :o

lol

[EZA100]

thinking about the yokohama dragons what do you thinks

Spink already has the Hong Kong Dragons ;)

I was talking about it earlier, but didn't post it anywhere official...

I wanted my team to be the 'Hong Kong Dongs'

Guess PB and I can't name our team that :(

:'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(

[BB67th]

Well I will lock in the name Manilla Folders then.

[Jay]

i think the Asia 15s draft should begin at the end of the afl season...reason: say dane swan does his ACL in the granny, and some poor bloke picked him up in the draft!!! May as well wait till end of season to avoid any surprises! Also maybe the '2-hour online rule' is a tad harsh...few technical problems and your pick is gone! The 24-hour rule is fair enough, dont want to see anyone gettin rushed into a bad pick... Cheers :)

[Justin Bieber]

Well I will lock in the name Manilla Folders then.

First team to fold?? Haha

[Spinking]

Well I will lock in the name Manilla Folders then.

First team to fold?? Haha

Too young for Dad jokes Lez  :D

[Justin Bieber]

Well I will lock in the name Manilla Folders then.

First team to fold?? Haha

Too young for Dad jokes Lez  :D

....

[nostradamus]

Great job with the rules Colli  8)

l'd like to put in my 2 cents worth for a couple though.....

1. l really like the captain (c) x 2 and vice-captain (vc) x 1.5, but have a problem with the sub taking their place in the event of either not playing. l feel that it has the potential to have too bigger impact on a team, especially in the event of late withdrawals.
Do you think naming a deputy-vice-captain (dvc) would work??

The way l see this working is........

a. lf both c and vc play then the status quo is mantained and the dvc still scores the same as usual.
b. lf the c doesn't play then the vc becomes c, and the dvc becomes vc.
c. lf the vc doesn't play then the c remains as is, and the dvc becomes the vc.

l think this is fairer because your teams c and vc will come from the 3 players that you believe will be the highest scorers in any partiular round. Rather than either of your 2 best picks and someone who didn't even make your best squad, in the event of a withdrawal.

2. The home ground advantage rule....... l personally like the system used in the other comps, i.e. double points for lowest scorer for the home team. l think its fairer.
l'd also like to make a suggestion withrespect to home ground advantage during finals.......l don't think there should be any at all. The double chance for the top 4 teams should be the only advantage given in my opinion, and apart from that all games should be played on their merits, and shall the best team win.

l hope l explained them well enough and didn't ramble too much