Who to bring in as M6?

[jamez_1983]

Hi guys,

Looking at my last upgrade this week.
jmac is out and not sure who to come in.
i have $254K in the bank.

Current mids - Ablett, Jelwood, Pendles, Thompson, Boyd, Jmac (Gibson, D.Smith)

As it stands, with a straight swap, i can afford the likes of  JPK, Rockliff, Stanton, Sloane, M.Murphy.

Trying to avoid it, but could do a downgrade and get Swan/Watson etc.

Thoughts?

[Migy119]

Don't waste 2 trads. Mark Murphy is a gun I think his the best of those opions

[Spinking]

How many trades left? If you have, say 8, then a downgrade to get to Swan is worth doing

If you have any less than 5 I would go to Murphy or Rocky. Watch price though  - Murph should drop again this week.

Good luck.

[kilbluff1985]

Personally don't like any of those options besides maybe Sloane who has a easy run home

How many trades you got left cause Swan or Watson would give you an awesome midfield with no weak links

[kilbluff1985]

Don't waste 2 trads. Mark Murphy is a gun I think his the best of those opions

he cant handle a tag which he will get for sure now that Judd's out

[jamez_1983]

4 trades  :-[

[tbagrocks]

nothing wrong with getting JPK, I wouldn't get Sloaneburger, just seems to not be getting as much ball atm and being used as half forward, don't be spooked by Murph either, we know he's a superstar, look at his previous years ave for proof!

[Marcos83]

JPK is the best of the lot, not scoring as well as start of year but still averages well and dominates games with clearances, possesions, tackles, goals....the lot. JUNMP ON

[Samm79]

nothing wrong with getting JPK, I wouldn't get Sloaneburger, just seems to not be getting as much ball atm and being used as half forward, don't be spooked by Murph either, we know he's a superstar, look at his previous years ave for proof!

Agree, would go Murph and bag the extra $$. At 460K he's too cheap to pass up

[jamez_1983]

nothing wrong with getting JPK, I wouldn't get Sloaneburger, just seems to not be getting as much ball atm and being used as half forward, don't be spooked by Murph either, we know he's a superstar, look at his previous years ave for proof!

Agree, would go Murph and bag the extra $$. At 460K he's too cheap to pass up

Murph makes the most sense financially.
Just not sure if he can reach a good score with a heavy tag.

[chadsta112]

I'm in a similar boat. I'm outing Mcdonald this week if he gets named and was originally going to bring in Murphy next week. I'm 95% sure his price will drop and the game over the weekend will show if he can cope with the tag. Either he or Carazzo should cop it given recent form from carrots. Downgrade Mcdonald this week and then wait a week for a better look.

[locknload]

LoL at Carrazzo getting tagged! Goose.
It is really hard to say no to Murphy at that price.
I dont mind rocky and redden either.
If money is no object I would look at mitchell or even A Swallow.

[The Bomber]

Lolz. Carrazzo tags Griffen. Picken tags Carrazzo... who tags Picken now?

[Capper]

I would just do a straight swap to sloane

[jamez_1983]

Lolz. Carrazzo tags Griffen. Picken tags Carrazzo... who tags Picken now?

Joseph, and Griffen will tag him.

Circle of Life.Complete