Shaw V's Scotland

[gav139]

what are ppls thoughts?

[Madmax75]

Shaw higher ceiling and Scotland usually max score is around a 100.

[upthemaidens]

scotland more consistant..    cant be sure with shaw, you'll get more grey hairs with him

[billnats]

I went Scotland just last week... regretted it after Shaw scored around 30 points more. But as everyone is saying, Scotland will get you 90+ every week, whilst Shaw will have a stinker much too often. I rather the safety of points so Scotland for me.

[The Bomber]

The points scored from here on in will be basically the same. Scotland as mentioned by basically everyone will get the 90 or so every week where as Shaw will have the massive weeks (and the low ones). Shaw is good if you need big scores to beat an opponent. (Thanks Shaw for covering for Suckling)...)

[Spinking]

Have had both at one stage or another and much prefer Scotland. Doesn't get big scores often but is usually good for 90 - 100. Shaw much more up and down.

[Colliwobblers]

scotland for safety and a very decent average, shaw is a seasaw carrots the best bet if you don't have him he'd be on top of my defender shopping list

[bartyboys]

My thoughts are same as mad mans , shaw can score higher. Plus calf injuries at a grand age are harder to overcome .

[upthemaidens]

My thoughts are same as mad mans , shaw can score higher. Plus calf injuries at a grand age are harder to overcome .

then Shaw will have a brain snap and get a club suspension cause hes a idiot,, he pretty much does something stupid every year. why should this year be any different..
   also Shaw can be tagged out of games, you dont want that during a sudden death finals match

[bartyboys]

We all know supercoach is about taking risks !

[upthemaidens]

We all know supercoach is about taking risks !

yeah like picking up Geary earlier in the year,  risks yeah tell me about it ::)