thoughts -take 2

[Alex7089]

here is my second attempt at my Team.

Backs- Goddard, Newman, Gilbee, C. Cornes, Houli, Raines, S. Hill (Rance, Lisle)

Mids- G. Ablett, Judd, J. Selwood, Gibbs, Foley, D. Rich ( Meredith, M. Robinson)

Rucks- Petrie, Hille ( Trengrove, D. Currie)

Forwards- Deledio, Chapman, J. Reiwoldt, R. Houlihan, Higgins, Skipworth, Zieblell ( Gumbleton, J. Grant)

thoughts.
Alex.

[ong111]

Trengrove is injured and i would look at moving Houlihan to the Backline.

[Alex7089]

have put houlihan back in place of houli.
Replaced Trengrove with Sellar.
Roughead forward in place of houlihan.

Thoughts.
Alex.

[Alex7089]

does no replies mean it is good?

[Griff]

who is Meredith?

[Alex7089]

who is Meredith?

he plays for sydney but i have recently traded him for beams

[jimmyha]

you seem a bit weak down forward..

[Alex7089]

new team
Backs- Goddard, Newman, Bock, C. Cornes, Grimes, Raines, S. Hill (Rance, Lisle)

Mids- G. Ablett, Judd, J. Selwood, Goodes, Foley, D. Rich ( D. Beams, M. Robinson)

Rucks- Petrie, Hille ( Sellar, D. Currie)

Forwards- Deledio, Pavlich, J. Reiwoldt, Roughead, Higgins, Skipworth, Zieblell ( Gumbleton, J. Grant)

[sobeyyy]

Nice team

Just b careful with grimes nd hill both on field. May not play every game. Forward line can be a bit weaker this yr due to cash cows. higgins, skipworth, yarren, sidebottom, ziebell can all b used. Give them a go. Wat do u think of rucks this yr, bigger yr from petrie or cox. Not too sure on cox? Nd roughead, is he in 4 a big yr mayb a new role up the ground more?

Wat do u think bout them??

[Alex7089]

Nice team

Just b careful with grimes nd hill both on field. May not play every game. Forward line can be a bit weaker this yr due to cash cows. higgins, skipworth, yarren, sidebottom, ziebell can all b used. Give them a go. Wat do u think of rucks this yr, bigger yr from petrie or cox. Not too sure on cox? Nd roughead, is he in 4 a big yr mayb a new role up the ground more?

Wat do u think bout them??

I agree with the whole grimes and Hill thing the only thing that made me choose 'em both was Grimes 150 in his practice match and people are saying Melbourne have said he could be a future captain.(thats just what I heard)
With hill i just thought that palmer and ibbotson both got heaps of time on ground last year...
Perhaps I should bring petterd otr hurley in for grimes? Or should I trade Hill?

Thoughts.
Alex.

[sobeyyy]

Nah, leave grimes, should b a good money maker. Im a melbourne supportor and agree he will get tym on ground but try and get bench ppl who will play and make u money. Leave Hill, i have him on my field, should b a good investment aswell. I dunno bout Hurley as i have heard he will play full abck and not score too well, Not sure. Wat do u think bout roughead and cox and petrie. Who's in 4 a bigger yr, cox or petrie, and how will roughead go,, is he in 4 a good money making yr. Would u choose him ova richo??

Thoughts?

[Watto]

Don't get Petrie, replace with McIntosh then trade Grimes for Petterd

Good team otherwise

[Alex7089]

Don't get Petrie, replace with McIntosh then trade Grimes for Petterd

Good team otherwise

What is wrong with pertrie? How is HMac better than him?
As long as Hurley doesn't get injured he should play!
Petterd is fighting Grimes and Cheney for a spot in the side

[Watto]

HMAC is better coz he's about 200k cheaper, and they score about the same in most matches

Grimes is looking the better of him/Petterd, Cheney is only a chance is either of them get injured

Yes, Hurley will play, but he'll be a full-back (or CHB) playing on the gun forwards. Look at Nathan Brown from Collingwood, he played a similar role to what Hurley will, and he averaged only 51 per game. Maybe get Schoenmakers/Dawson/Rance/Suban instead (this will save some $$ as well)

[Alex7089]

HMAC is better coz he's about 200k cheaper, and they score about the same in most matches

Grimes is looking the better of him/Petterd, Cheney is only a chance is either of them get injured

Yes, Hurley will play, but he'll be a full-back (or CHB) playing on the gun forwards. Look at Nathan Brown from Collingwood, he played a similar role to what Hurley will, and he averaged only 51 per game. Maybe get Schoenmakers/Dawson/Rance/Suban instead (this will save some $$ as well)

Zac Dawson is useless.
I think I would rather have a player who will play and score mildly than a player who plays in patches when players are injured.
Do you really think I want to put the reigning premiers rookies in my 22?
Not really.
I dought Hurley will play on Brown and Pav before Fletch and Ryder do.