hanley/birlchall/suckling done my head in

Started by dejan, July 13, 2012, 02:47:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

hanley/birlchall/suckling done my head in

hanley
2 (8.3%)
sukling
5 (20.8%)
birchall
17 (70.8%)

Total Members Voted: 1

dejan


fertalong

I'd go Birch ahead of Suckling just because of consistency.

Hanley 3rd for mine. He has ha high ceiling and is in great form, but is also capable of a 40. If you are going for league, Hanley probably isn't a good idea because if he gets a 40 in the finals, that could make the difference.

Alka

It's easy.

Birchall > Suckling > Hanley.

Hanley has scored well against bad teams. His tons have been against: Melb twice, Gold Coast, GWS, Bulldogs, and Sydney. Sydney being the exception there. He faces Gold Coast next week, and the Bulldogs in the finals, but otherwise faces tough teams, and I expect his scoring to suffer. So forget about him.

Suckling is better at SC than DT, but is still a good DT option. Everyone here will say the same thing about his ceiling being higher. Look at his scores, and his big scores (120+) are against GWS and Melbourne. He should play well against the Bulldogs this week, and Gold Coast in round 21. So two big scores there, and the rest should average in the 80s. A good option, however...

Birchall is the consistent one. Scores well, and is slightly more DT inclined. Suckling may out-score him in the few games he has more freedom, but it will be minimal, and Birch should average more for the season.

dejan

cheers guys thanks alot i dunno how to cheer if u let me know ill cheer u guys

Justin Bieber

Birchman, wins every day of the week. No contest.

Artax


Alka

Quote from: dejan on July 13, 2012, 03:56:36 PM
cheers guys thanks alot i dunno how to cheer if u let me know ill cheer u guys

No problem, I was making the same decision myself, so it's good to write it out and convince myself it's the right move even more :P

The cheer/boo option is just under our names, it should be in blue font.

treebeard

Quote from: dejan on July 13, 2012, 03:56:36 PM
cheers guys thanks alot i dunno how to cheer if u let me know ill cheer u guys

You can't cheer/boo until you've made 50 posts. That one confused me for a while too.

superspud

Thinking of doing the final upgrades to my back line this week:

Hargrave > Scotland
Ellis > Suckling

That will leave me with:
Deledio, Goddard, Birchall, Suckling, Scotland, Carrazzo, Broughton (S Shaw, Darley)

Pretty happy with that, aside from Broughton I couldn't ask for much more.  ;D