2 Trades or 1 Trade - Save or Splurge

Started by KnightRyder, July 12, 2012, 10:04:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Option

Trade Dickson to Goodes - DPP Link + Upgrade - Stay on 3 trades
3 (33.3%)
Trade Waters to Suckling, Williams - Goodes - 2 Trades for Finals
6 (66.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

KnightRyder

Ok, so the question is do I go:

Option 1.
Use just 1 trade to get Goodes in for Dickson.  This means I get Goodes, which will leave Zorko as my M6 for now and Martin/Zorko can be M7 or F8 for the rest of the year.  However, it also means that I have Waters sitting on the bench for 3-5 weeks (if not more) and Marley Williams sitting idle on my bench for the rest of the year. Or

Option 2.
I use two trades to get rid of Waters and Bring in Goodes.  This obviously means I get rid of Waters and trade in Suckling (means I don't have to rely on Darley or Shaw till Waters is back).  It also means I can upgrade Marley Williams to Goodes - keeping Dickson as a reliable Forward Benchy if required.


My team currently is:

Backs: Heater, MJ, Carazzo, Birchall, Waters, Deledio, Sam Shaw (Goddard, Darley)

Mids: Swan, Ablett, Rockliff, Thompson, Boyd, Clay Smith (Martin, Williams)

Rucks: Maric, Jacobs (Campbell, Redden)

Forwards: Robbo, Beams, Sidebum, Pearce, Dangerfield, Dickson, Zorko (Franklin, Crozier)


1st or 2nd in my leagues and sitting at about 1,300 overall.  All opinions are welcome - Forgot to mention, before doing any of this I have 4 trades left and 133K in the bank.



Hagebear

I think option 2 is obviously better for ur team for the next 4 or so weeks but only having 2 trades for the rest of the year is sooo risky. not sure if i could do it. The way things have gone this year, trades will be golden from now on.

Flame


treebeard

I reckon save your trades. If you're going to make your league finals anyway, you're better to wait and see what happens over the next few weeks.