HELP! In a bit of a pickle! Please give suggestions

[t.thomas6]

Hey dudes and dude-lets,

Looking like a horror round this round. Here is my team (outs highlighted).
Was wondering who I should bring in for Waters and should I jump on Goodes for Porps this week as he has pretty much bottomed out price wise?

Backs: Deledio, Broughton, Waters, Shaw, Carrazzo, Clarke, Darley (Goddard, Bootsma)
Mids: Ablett, Watson, Kennedy, Mitchell, Priddis, Boyd (JMac, S. Gibson)
Rucks: Goldstein, Giles (Redden, Campbell)
Fwds: Buddy, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Chapman, Porps, Zorko, Patton (Martin, Hall)

Trades: 5, Bank: $27,900

So the questions are:
Waters...to Johnson, Birchall, Scotland, etc.
Should I upgrade Goodesy too?
Is there ANY other route I can take that I haven't thought of???

PLEASE COMMENT WITH SOME ADVICE :D

[bensl]

porps to goodes and waters to whoever u can afford?

[JT23]

porps to goodes, waters to carrots, heppell, malceski, scotland or M.Johnson  ;)

[Capper]

porps to goodes, waters to carrots, heppell, malceski, scotland or M.Johnson  ;)

not malceski

If you jump on Goodes you will need to downgrade someone for the cash

Do you have enough money to go Waters to MJ and Porps to Goodes??

Otherwise JMAC->Mcintyre, Waters->MJ/Porps->Goodes

[t.thomas6]

I upgraded Mal for Shaw at the perfect time :)

I DO have enough cash to do that trade, which was one I was thinking of. I was also thinking of getting rid of Hall, but I doubt I can do that this week :(

Any other suggestions?

[t.thomas6]

Cmon guys, other posts have had HEAPS of replys...this has had 2 :(

I NEED ALL YOUR HELP! :P

[The Bomber]

I think you have enough cash to go
Porps --> Goodes
Waters --> Suckling

But looking at your defence, you D7 is a lot weaker than your F6/7

Thinking instead Clarke --> Yarran and Waters --> Any defender (thinking Suckling or Birchall or Scotland)

from this you get min 30 ppg more (will end up more like 50 IMO on Yarrans current form compared to Porps)..whereas Porps-->Goodes will net about 20 ppg, (30 if lucky) and costs a lot more...

[t.thomas6]

Thanks for that mate :)

Good suggestions there. But is Goodes too Goodes (see what I did there  :P haha) to not pick now with his price bottomed out? Also Yarran is VERY patchy which is why I haven't picked him.

Also, would you pick Suckling over Johnson? and if so, why?

[BB67th]

Go for the Porps to Goodes upgrade and Waters to M Johnson. He is so solid and not many people have him at the moment.

[The Bomber]

Also, would you pick Suckling over Johnson? and if so, why?

Suckling capable of the higher score. Should average the same here on out.

[t.thomas6]

Freo have a pretty good run home though :P...

[t.thomas6]

Just had a new thought that COULD kill 2 birds with 1 stone...but it's risky...

Waters to Yarran
Hall to Goodes

THOUGHTS??? :o ::) 8)

[t.thomas6]

Hey guys, what do you think of the previous post???