Sylvia Vs Goodes

[Thedreamteamgod]

thinking of having one for F7
the ultimatum will be between Sylvia, Goodes and Zorko

vote away

[Toga]

goodes by a million country miles over sylv.

or keep zorkdaddy and conserve trades... that's what i'd be doing!

[Thedreamteamgod]

nono,
i keeping Zorko
the trade is Dickson for Sylvia or Goodsey

[Toga]

nono,
i keeping Zorko
the trade is Dickson for Sylvia or Goodsey

ohh ok then why did you say "the ultimatum will be between Sylvia, Goodes and Zorko"???

you should have said that in the first place!!!!! haha

definitely goodes far better and more consistent than sylvia there's really no decision to be made!!!! 8)

[Hagebear]

nono,
i keeping Zorko
the trade is Dickson for Sylvia or Goodsey

ohh ok then why did you say "the ultimatum will be between Sylvia, Goodes and Zorko"???

you should have said that in the first place!!!!! haha

definitely goodes far better and more consistent than sylvia there's really no decision to be made!!!! 8)

i think he means he already has zorko and is bringing in either goodes or sylvia a F7 or keep zorko as F7. Zorko seems to be good enough to hold F7. I reckon you could probably use the money elsewhere in your team but if you do decide to ring one in it has to be goodes. Sylvia has had the worst season in history and has been dropped. 2 good games doesnt mean hes back and goodsey is seasoned DT jet.

[gossiboy]

goodes by a million country miles over sylv.

or keep zorkdaddy and conserve trades... that's what i'd be doing!

+1. Goodes over Sylvia every day of the week.

[Windigo]

Goodes won't let you down.

As a Sylvia owner in the past....Don't get him. At his best he is a great DT option, but not consistent & dodgy injuries always happen...

[Spinking]

Goodes is your man.  Sylvia is way to up and down. 

If your issue is then whether they end up on the field ahead of Zorko, I'd have Z in there at the moment but with so many injuries out there you probably won't need to make a choice...

[its me lads]

sylvia will pump out a ton then get reported, Goodes is the best option by a bakers dozen.

[Thedreamteamgod]

Yes, but Sylvia now has a real midfield role at Melbourne is a ball Magnet.
I personally believe that Sylvia will average 100+ for the remainder of the season.
As i just dont think that Goodes will average approx 90.

Just my personal opinion, but Goodes over time has been known to be reliable