Rate the team

[Middo]

Defs:
Enright, Hodge, Gilbee, Mackie,
Kennelly, Hunt, Sheppard  Bench: Talia, Alex Silvagni

Mids:
Ablett, J.Selwood, M.Murphy, Vince
Cooney, Morabito  Bench: Sam Blease, Bastinac

Rucks:
Hille, Leuenberger  Bench: Vardy, McCauley

Fwds:
Riewoldt, Pavlich, S.Johnson, Franklin,
Bradshaw, Ziebell, Gary Rohan Bench: Lobbe, Tapscott

I dont want u to tell me my rucks are bad because i am aware of that but thoughts on the rest of the team??

[Resch]

By downgrading rucks you have gained one extra mid gun.  Your risk that lost points will be made up.

Rookies in backline and forward are a high risk of not playing.  You will need to find two that play during NAB Cup.  This year mid rookies are much more likely to play.

Nothing wrong with your gun choice in back and mid.  Fwds will be a roller coaster with Franklin/Johnson/Bradshaw all likely to score very high or very low.  Maybe get some more consistent players who get the ball more.

Geelong heavy team too.  Not that it is a bad thing but if it is a feral day at K Park may devrease your score.

7/10

[Middo]

do u mean rookies on field or bench?

[Resch]

do u mean rookies on field or bench?

Both but mainly field.  Sheppard is a chance if he goes OK but not necessarly a lock.  Rohan similarly but a lot less of a chance - especially at Sydney.   If your bench isn't playing you aren't making money to upgrade with

Although, as with all rookies, NAB Cup form and round 1 teams will change thinking so at the moment it is purely speculation and everyone will be watching carefully. 

[tferrier18]

Resch is right. From what we know at the moment Rohan won't get much gametime, sheppard won't be a star. It might be worth having 3 rookies in the mid and upgrading your forwards.

What's everyone elses opinion of having 3 rookies in the mid?

[Middo]

rohan out for watts maybe? i think scully and trengove wont play first couple of rounds so who do i downgrade to?