Porpise or Giles to trade

[littleblueboy2906]

BACKS: Goddard, Deledio, Enright, Birchall, Lake, Malceski, Suckling (Smedts, S.Shaw)
MIDS: Pendles, Ablett, Boyd, Priddis, Beams, Scotty T (Sexton, Ledger)
RUCKS: Cox, Giles (Stephenson, Campbell)
FWDS: Franklin, Martin, Sidebottom, Tippett, Harvey, Porpylzia, Zorko (Milera, Cameron)

3 Trades, 6,4 00k in bank

Was thinking of downgrading Ledger but there is no point because he is more of a chance than playing than Sexton (season injury) so can trade either Sexton to a MID.... or I could trade Terry Milera to either a MID or FWD can swap Sexton forward

then depending on who to trade (more likely to be Milera cos more money and Sexton has got MID/FWD swing)

can upgrade anyone... looking at one of Porpylzia (6th FWD ATM) or Giles (2nd Ruck)

The one that I do trade the other has gotta to be a KEEPER looking at Porpise to go.. can go to either a MID or FWD

Who should I get?

Or should I just hold 3 trades, after I do a double will have 1 left but im not too worried...... wanna get overall back up its 48,000 ATM and 10th in main league (got easy games though) but need to win them all to get to finals

Cheers for Help!

[charliesheen]

Timing of the trade is not great, price of rucks is expensive and Giles has lost cash.

Its going to be tough now.  I would look at getting an M6 and pushing Beam's forwards. 

Cameron > McIntyre
Milera > Premium mid

That leaves 1 trade for injury and Giles as R2.

[quinny88]

48 overall?

Wouldnt have thought so.. ???

[mzunguman]

tough position your in with only 3 trades... same as me though  ::)

But i reckon you got to risk it for the biscuit and i like @charliesheen's idea

[Capper]

48 overall?

Wouldnt have thought so.. ???

yeh doesnt seem right

I would hold on to the trades

[littleblueboy2906]

48 overall?

Wouldnt have thought so.. ???

yeh dont no how really, eski been warming up the pine lately maybe why but he is starting to get some confidence and form (ton on the weekend) and brining in boomer when fyfe went down early in the year boomer hasnt been the greatest

[charliesheen]

Whats the best mid you can afford from this?

Cameron > McIntyre
Milera > Premium mid

[upthemaidens]

even though i cant believe that team is 48th, i did last week just look at a few teams above me and the first one i randomly selected had kruzer and giles as the ruck combo :o  and that team was in the top 50 so i guess anything is possible..

on your trades, you have weak benches and think tippet is out for abit.. so probably best to keep porps for the time being.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Whats the best mid you can afford from this?

Cameron > McIntyre
Milera > Premium mid

+1. Good advice. Beams into fwds. Keep Porps, I think he will be a valuable F8

[littleblueboy2906]

Crap, sorry guys I meant 48,000k!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[littleblueboy2906]

Whats the best mid you can afford from this?

Cameron > McIntyre
Milera > Premium mid

505k Mid no one really

[billy2010]

Keep the porp for a few more rounds, he's been hitting some form in the last month and has a lowish breakeven. Giles past his peak so offload asap. Mcevoy a good option.

[glam77]

Crap, sorry guys I meant 48,000k!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

48,000k equals 48,000,000

so i'm guessing you actually mean 48k ie 48,000.

[littleblueboy2906]

yeah that ^ sorry

thoughts on what I should be doing???

[MLS]

What about this, a little left field.

What about Giles-> Pattison (R/F) and Milera -> Roughead (R/F)

This week Campbell can be at R2 and Roughy in the FWD line, then swing Roughy back to rucks when Martin, Tippet & Franklin are back. Then effectively Zorko can cover FWD, MID and RUC.

Roughy should smash it with Buddy out too. 

I did the sums, you have the cash