Ask Q (6/7/12)

[Master Q]

Hey guys and welcome to Ask Q! You guys know how it works! Ask me a question and I'll give you my honest opinion.

PS: Don't be afraid to Cheer  ;)

Deadline: 6:30 PM (Sorry for the lateness, I just came back from a movie  ;) )

[Windigo]

Who would you get under 345K in the defense?

Yarran
Hibberd
Andy Moore

Thanks.  ;)

[henry]

I made a thread, but I'll ask for your pearls of wisdom too on this particular matter: Who should I start out of Taylor Adams, Devon Smith and Sam Gibson to replace Dusty Martin.

Unfortunately I have a fear of cheering meaning it is unlikely I will be able to cheer you. This strange fear or cheeraphobia as it is known among us medical professionals can result in the subject acting rashly, such as trading out grimes after round 3 for conca :-[

[Master Q]

Who would you get under 345K in the defense?

Yarran
Hibberd
Andy Moore

Thanks.  ;)

None

I made a thread, but I'll ask for your pearls of wisdom too on this particular matter: Who should I start out of Taylor Adams, Devon Smith and Sam Gibson to replace Dusty Martin.

Unfortunately I have a fear of cheering meaning it is unlikely I will be able to cheer you. This strange fear or cheeraphobia as it is known among us medical professionals can result in the subject acting rashly, such as trading out grimes after round 3 for conca :-[

Gibson

[Blairholt]

colin sylvia? good for a cheap f7?

[essendon2]

who to captain out of Watson or Stevie J?

Martin --> Sylvia so I can afford Hargrave --> Carrazzo?

[Holz]

3. Redden to Pattison and Clarke to Carrots 50k left + 1 trade left
4. Stephenson to Pattison and Clarke to Carrots 70k left +`1 trade left
5. Redden to Pattison and Hargrave to Carrots 70k left + 1 trade left
6. Stephneson to Pattison and Hagrave to Carrots 90k left + 1 trade left


Going to do one of them but im not sure which is the best. All these guys im trading out are on my bench.

[Master Q]

colin sylvia? good for a cheap f7?

Not in my opinion

who to captain out of Watson or Stevie J?

Martin --> Sylvia so I can afford Hargrave --> Carrazzo?

1. No other options? I'd go J out of those 2.

2. Not worth it in my opinion.

[essendon2]

colin sylvia? good for a cheap f7?

Not in my opinion

who to captain out of Watson or Stevie J?

Martin --> Sylvia so I can afford Hargrave --> Carrazzo?

1. No other options? I'd go J out of those 2.

2. Not worth it in my opinion.

Jobe or Stevie Jay? haha
and why?

[henry]

Who would you get under 345K in the defense?

Yarran
Hibberd
Andy Moore

Thanks.  ;)

None

I made a thread, but I'll ask for your pearls of wisdom too on this particular matter: Who should I start out of Taylor Adams, Devon Smith and Sam Gibson to replace Dusty Martin.

Unfortunately I have a fear of cheering meaning it is unlikely I will be able to cheer you. This strange fear or cheeraphobia as it is known among us medical professionals can result in the subject acting rashly, such as trading out grimes after round 3 for conca :-[

Gibson

Thanks, I did in fact manage to get a breakthrough and overcome my fears, and I think you may find that somehow you have gone up a cheer.

[Master Q]

3. Redden to Pattison and Clarke to Carrots 50k left + 1 trade left
4. Stephenson to Pattison and Clarke to Carrots 70k left +`1 trade left
5. Redden to Pattison and Hargrave to Carrots 70k left + 1 trade left
6. Stephneson to Pattison and Hagrave to Carrots 90k left + 1 trade left


Going to do one of them but im not sure which is the best. All these guys im trading out are on my bench.

Big commitment to get Carrots in the team. Personally I would never leave myself with 1 trade this early in the season... BUT if you are going to do one of these I would do the first one.

[miegs3]

Hi Q, undecided on moves this week.

8 trades and $248,300 in the bank.

Team:
DEF Deledio, Goddard, Suckling, Scotland, Adcock, Broughton, Darley (Shaw, Smedts)
MID Boyd, Mitchell, Ablett, Selwood, McDonald, Gibson (Pendlebury, Miles)
RUC  Cox, Giles (Sandilands, Redden)
FWDS  Franklin, Chapman, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, Dickson, Zorko, Sidebottom (Tomlinson, Elliott)

I want to bring in Carrazzo to finish off my backs but not sure who I should move.

Darley is worth the most but scores the most (out again this week now).
Shaw won't go far but good js as bench.
Smedts has low breakeven and allows swap with Tomlinson.
Tomlinson is low scorer but allows swap with Smedts for cover.

What do people think about downgrading Sandi to Campbell?
I'd like to bring in Swan & Maric, but thinking it isn't the week.

Cheers

[Master Q]

Jobe or Stevie Jay? haha
and why?

Not a fan of Sylvia :P

Thanks, I did in fact manage to get a breakthrough and overcome my fears, and I think you may find that somehow you have gone up a cheer.

Haha, at least you gave it too someone who deserves it  ;)

[HDm90]

Who do you think is the best rookie defender to get in?

Need to downgrade Darley and upgrade Hargrave to Carrots.

Thanks :)

[Goibon]

Treloar or Adams as F7 this week? The other will cover Buddy as emergency so i'll probably end up getting both scores anyway.