Hibberd as a good D7?

[dicey7]

Hey guys i was just wondering what your thoughts would be on having Hibberd from ess as D7?

Take out his hammy injury against coll he averages 82,  scoring 2 90's and 1 ton from 7 games without injury low score of 65

I can go Bugg > Carrazzo but hibberd could be a good POD for me and also gives me an extra 48K to upgrade hall later on.

[Ajax22]

Carrazzo should be a 15 pt better player than Hibberd do for only 50k more you have to take him.

[SydneyRox]

From what I am reading Hibberd wont be too unique, a lot of people looking to save trades now and bringing him in looks like a good upgrade right now

[Zombie2.5]

I think you just have to go Carrots. Proven, and he's a VERY cheap price. He's already got a price drop from that 1, its enough! Don't go looking for even more of a bargain..... ;)

I think you're overthinking it, just go with the gun Carrots.

[DT Gun]

do you think marc murphy returning changes carrazzos scoring?

[Ziplock]

do you think marc murphy returning changes carrazzos scoring?

valid question, but I wouldn't think so- at the very least, he was chopping up before he got injured, and is a proven premium at a discount price.

[Colliwobblers]

carrots played a lot in the midfield all last season with murph there he just tagged more and has gotten better this season at winning his own ball while playing on opposition midfielders, don't think it would change much, not sure murph was getting much of it before his injury anyway and carrots was before his..

on hibberd he is much more suitable and popular for SC than DT, the sheer numbers to get you want you want in DT he doesn't get regularly.... YET

[essendon2]

Hargrave --> Hibberd??

[Toga]

Considering him... He looks good but I reckon i might take a punt on dempsey or maybe bachar houli....

Any chance of bachar getting more of a run on the wing now that dusty and connors are out?

[nickstiges]

Considering him... He looks good but I reckon i might take a punt on dempsey or maybe bachar houli....

Any chance of bachar getting more of a run on the wing now that dusty and connors are out?

Doubtful, Conca & Foley will probably be back into the side this week and one will play off the wing.

[Toga]

Considering him... He looks good but I reckon i might take a punt on dempsey or maybe bachar houli....

Any chance of bachar getting more of a run on the wing now that dusty and connors are out?

Doubtful, Conca & Foley will probably be back into the side this week and one will play off the wing.

yeah true dat, i'm still considering houls or maybe even the skip chris newman for the old D7...

[powersuperkents]

Carrots is super cheap! Carrots is going to skyrocket your team value after this round! Carrots averages 105 taking after his bad game! only 7% of teams have Carrots! and Carrots is a premium and a super premium defender second to Deledio if you take away his injury game!!!! If there even a question? I'm shocked you would even think of choosing Hibberd over Carrots if there was a $200k price difference between the two I would still find a way to make the $200k to get Carrots and avoid Hibberd!!! You never turn down a 100+ averaging back especially at $370k!!!!!!!!!!!!

GO WITH CARROTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You will regret going with Hibberd for the rest of the season when other teams are getting weekly 100+ scores and your cheering over a one off 90!!!

[essendon2]

can't afford carrots for Hargrave , only got 370k to spend

[Toga]

can't afford carrots for Hargrave , only got 370k to spend

+1

Carrots is super cheap! Carrots is going to skyrocket your team value after this round! Carrots averages 105 taking after his bad game! only 7% of teams have Carrots! and Carrots is a premium and a super premium defender second to Deledio if you take away his injury game!!!! If there even a question? I'm shocked you would even think of choosing Hibberd over Carrots if there was a $200k price difference between the two I would still find a way to make the $200k to get Carrots and avoid Hibberd!!! You never turn down a 100+ averaging back especially at $370k!!!!!!!!!!!!

GO WITH CARROTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You will regret going with Hibberd for the rest of the season when other teams are getting weekly 100+ scores and your cheering over a one off 90!!!

obviously carrots or hanley are a better option but to do that we would have to make extra trades which I can't and im sure others cant do because ive only got 3 trades left!

[essendon2]

can't afford carrots for Hargrave , only got 370k to spend

+1

Carrots is super cheap! Carrots is going to skyrocket your team value after this round! Carrots averages 105 taking after his bad game! only 7% of teams have Carrots! and Carrots is a premium and a super premium defender second to Deledio if you take away his injury game!!!! If there even a question? I'm shocked you would even think of choosing Hibberd over Carrots if there was a $200k price difference between the two I would still find a way to make the $200k to get Carrots and avoid Hibberd!!! You never turn down a 100+ averaging back especially at $370k!!!!!!!!!!!!

GO WITH CARROTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You will regret going with Hibberd for the rest of the season when other teams are getting weekly 100+ scores and your cheering over a one off 90!!!

obviously carrots or hanley are a better option but to do that we would have to make extra trades which I can't and im sure others cant do because ive only got 3 trades left!

exactly the same.
hurn or Hibberd or keep Hargrave?

got two donuts in fwd line cause sexton and crozier can't fill in for Martin and buddy