Scotland vs. Waters

[bombers11]

having trouble spitting them, expert advice?

[TheBeatles]

Waters - eagles have a few games at subi to finish and waters will play loose man and rack em up!!!!

[Torpedo10]

Waters, can give massive scores.

[Thunderstruck]

Waters for me

[Marcos83]

hold for a couple of weeks becasue waters has a high break even. Will drop and pick him up when totally bottomed out.

[Flame]

I have Waters but really want Scotland as my last defender! Not sure if I have the cash though! Scotland is a DT gun! Reliable tons every week! Can't go wrong with him!

[HBTD22]

I have a man crush on Beau... he's just an animal. I would usually suggest going for the player in the better team in cases like this. Waters for me.

[ScottieD]

DT Averages   Waters    Scotland
2004               53.9         70.6
2005                              76.3
2006               66.2       104.0
2007               78.6         99.8
2008               68.8         89.5
2009                              86.3
2010               87.5         93.1
2011               68.3         99.7
2012               97.3         97.6

Games since 2004:  Waters 96; Scotland 177 = Scotland more durable (or just less crazy)

Price Waters $448,900; Scotland $428,900

I know WC are going great and Carlton bad... but come on...

[Spinking]

Much prefer Waters as a player.  Toughest bloke going around.  For DT though I'd go Scotland, just gets near it more often.

[Chopps]

scotland is more durable and a better history of scoring, considered carazzo?

[Master Q]

Scotland for me.