Broughton (SPUD) dilemma

[Jormas]

he is spudding up, projected to leak 40K over 3 weeks with a BE of 123...

Thinking of trading him with 4 trades left to finish my backline:

Goddard, Birchall, Lids, Carrazzo, Waters, BROUGHTON, Dempsey (Shaw, Darley)

thinking of a straight swap to Enright or Suckling?

Leave a commenbt below; cheers.

[Justin Bieber]

Well one of my new favourites Pearce Hanley has been killing it.

If I could afford to, he would come in for me.

Lock him in for D4 next year.

[Jormas]

Got 185 with Broughton, Shaw, and Darley.

Could trade either Darley or Broughts.

Darley has about 70K to make though.

[Justin Bieber]

The question is: Will Darley make it back into the team?

Also I wouldn't get old man Enright, get Hanley.

[Andrew]

Got 185 with Broughton, Shaw, and Darley.

Could trade either Darley or Broughts.

Darley has about 70K to make though.

If you're looking to get rid of anyone in your defence, try to get rid of Shaw. You'll need Dempsey/Broughton as cover for the rest of the year (i.e. this week with Goddard probably getting suspended) and as already asked, will Darley make it back into the team? If not named this week you could have the best defence going around by upgrading Shaw, who probably has peaked in price as he's a 30s man. Downgrade elsewhere (Tom Campbell?) to afford the Sam Shaw upgrade, then if Darley does return he can earn you more cash and be downgraded for your final luxury upgrade.

[Ricochet]

yeh he's been below par the last two weeks but the 5 weeks before that were 98,100,80,90,99
in fact if you go back another 4 weeks he had 109, 92, 88, 75
Everyone has a poor game here and there, even Ablett (by his standards)
i don't see the point in dumping him just because he's has two poor weeks

[Ziplock]

the issue is lyons been playing him forward, and he just doesn't have the natural instincts of a forward. Once he gets back into defence he should be right.

[LF]

You can't blame Broughton he is being played out of position in the forward line for god only knows what reason.
Once the idiot coach realizes he is of no value to the Dockers there he will get moved back.

[HBTD22]

Broughton definitely isn't a spud! Couple of bad games here and there doesn't make him a spud, like previously mentioned he's just being played out of position lately.

[Affliction]

I would keep him based on how many trades you have left. Save your trades for later in the year you will need them.

[Scrads]

Jormas, your first dilemma is you have a team.

Keep Gregory.

[daz77]

It is too late in the season.
Just hold him.

[Ajax22]

You should definitely trade him out for Enright. That would be sure to solve your inconsistency worries  ::)

[andyandy89]

He scored a very respectible 75 against a formidable opponent, in a tagging role in a position that he is only getting used to - stop whining, he'll be right

[Windigo]

Hanley can put in some shockers as well.

I'd keep Greg.