consistancy vs bench cover(will cheer for answers)

[disco1992]

hey lads and ladies(maybe)?

Ive hit a snag with my final upgrade i have two main options i want to get carrazzo in for sure and my other is a premium forward!

option 1: hargrave ->carrazzo and shiel -> chapman leaves me with 17k and ellis as D8
optoin 2: ellis -> carrazzo and shiel ->(DPP swap) johnson (or cheaper premo [goodes etc]) johnson leaves me with 100$ change

my backs are lids, god, waters, broughton, johnson, hargrave (ellis,shaw)
forwards are steele,buddy, beams, robbo, danger, dusty, zorko (adams, dell'olio)

i guess i'm asking is it better to have chapman and weak back cover or stevie j or similar and hargrave as D8???

cheer for advice

[juddy5x3]

Ellis or Shaw SHOULD be ok....Chappy better bet than SJ due to consistency. Robinson/Goodes/Martin all worth a shout. Probabaly robinson if you don't have him.

[Fireballz]

Shaw and Ellis are good bench cover. Option 1 all the way!

[nostradamus]

definately option 1

[Colliwobblers]

agree option one, chappy more consistant and he had his little restys now hopefuly he is fresh for the run home.

[Ash A]

chapman has been the ultimate dream team forward for the last 4 years for his consistent 100+
might need to wait for decision on his fitness.
Ellis is fine for D8
option 1 for me :)

[Ajax22]

Option 3 and go with Goodes. I'd be happy seeing Goodes matched up against Chappy most weeks and it's about this time of year that Goodes pulls his finger out and turns it on. Might take another week or 2 to get there but I fully expect him to go bang at some point soon.
Also its reasonably common to have players out this year and Hargrave is a 20-30 pt better player than Ellis that isn't at a risk of being vested

[Holz]

Robinson and hargrave easy in my opinon. first up i tihnk he will beat chappy anyway, is also alot more durable. Im not saying chappy will miss, but he has a higher chance than robbo. Also hargrave might get in to that kick to kick stuff of the half back. hargrave has the potential to average 80+ from here on. Ellis doesnt

[Ajax22]

Robinson and hargrave easy in my opinon. first up i tihnk he will beat chappy anyway, is also alot more durable. Im not saying chappy will miss, but he has a higher chance than robbo. Also hargrave might get in to that kick to kick stuff of the half back. hargrave has the potential to average 80+ from here on. Ellis doesnt

Pretty sure it said he already has Robbo...

[disco1992]

Cheers guys hopefully chappy plays this weekend, and that's the thing I like about Geelong they either rest their stars or they play a full game none of this vesting shower! I think chappy looks the best for my team :)

[disco1992]

Does goddards suspension change anything??

[Football Factory]

Option 1 ..  cant say Hargrave has good JS the way he has been playing and you get CHAPPY

[Windigo]

Chapman is still one of the premier DT fwds going around.  ;)

Stevie J too up/down this year for my liking.

[Ricochet]

Option one pretty easily mate, get rid of Hargs.
Chappy's had his rest now so should be right for the rest of the year... hopefully  ;D

[disco1992]

Do you guys think chappy might go down in price in the next fortnight? Because I may be able to do a sneaky trade to get chappy for Ellis in a fort night!! But Ellis rise of 20k and chappy dropping by 30 seems unlikely in the next fortnight.

Wishful thinking