Is it worth depleting ruck stocks for...

Started by nickstiges, July 01, 2012, 11:05:23 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

nickstiges

An easy main league game & long term gain this coming week?

In a bit of a predicament with trying to get Carrots in this week, going to go Bugg > Carrazzo to complete my defence, but I'm 55k odd short.

Just thinking of ways around it and an idea that comes to mind is dropping Giles for Tom Campbell this week leaving me with around 200k in the bank for Big O/Redden > Maric/Goldy/Ryder/Griffen next week.
Starting rucks would be Cox vs North & Campbell vs Freo for Round 15.

Thoughts? or am I completely mad?

Fireballz

Why not go Redden -> Campbell this week and then go Giles -> Maric next week?

Zombie2.5

Quote from: Fireballz on July 01, 2012, 11:14:02 PM
Why not go Redden -> Campbell this week and then go Giles -> Maric next week?
Yeah, since you only need 55k, it sounds much better...

nickstiges

Quote from: Zombie2.5 on July 01, 2012, 11:17:39 PM
Quote from: Fireballz on July 01, 2012, 11:14:02 PM
Why not go Redden -> Campbell this week and then go Giles -> Maric next week?
Yeah, since you only need 55k, it sounds much better...

I was hoping to maximize the amount of cash on hand for next week, question marks on Giles' potential for reaching his BE of 85 with his roller coaster form lately.

Rommas

Definitely contemplating going Redden > Campbell then Edwards > Carrots, will make the choice when teams are announced on Thursday to see if Campbell is even picked

Fireballz

Quote from: Rommas on July 01, 2012, 11:52:38 PM
Definitely contemplating going Redden > Campbell then Edwards > Carrots, will make the choice when teams are announced on Thursday to see if Campbell is even picked
They didn't drop him for Minson, who would take his spot if he was dropped now?

Ajax22

If its an easy league win then sure but I would wait and see if Brogan is named. If Giles were to get solo ruck duties then he should reach somewhere around his BE fairly easily I would think

Windigo

I think Giles confirmed this week that still is no need to trade him out with a solid 80 odd.