WHICH ONE TO DITCH

[yorgis]

Which ruckman should i ditch and for whom ?   need the cash . thanks guys

[mezzoculo]

Big O should go for Tom Campbell. Will net you north of $100k.
None of Capbell, Bigo O or Redden have any JS now but who cares if its your R4.

[yorgis]

dont have big 'O , and as i said i need the cash

[mezzoculo]

dont have big 'O , and as i said i need the cash

Yeah, my bad - meant Redden in for Campbell :-S

[yorgis]

no worries mezz thanx. gut feel says redders, but thought maybe there was another option staring me in the face,

so that i could make more cash

[Chelskiman]

Mumford tbh, though you would be left very short in the ruck department.  I started with Mummy and he gave me nothing but donuts early on.  I also wouldn't trust his on going back issues.

[Marcos83]

Silly to get rid of mummy seriously when he has came back. I think he will get back to his best. Personally I think downgrade kreuzer\giles to a rookie and then use the cash elsewhere. If you have heaps of trades then go kreuzer to cambell and upgrade other areas.

Others will say giles but the thing is if you see there scores it seems giles is more consitent and more reliable. Kreuzer is tossing up f##k all and really inconsitent.

[mezzoculo]

no worries mezz thanx. gut feel says redders, but thought maybe there was another option staring me in the face,

so that i could make more cash

I guess it depends on who you see as your final ruck pairing. It seems to be Mummy and Giles ATM, although you could upgrade Giles to (say) Roughy for only a little extra cash.

[Chelskiman]

Silly to get rid of mummy seriously when he has came back. I think he will get back to his best.

I can't see him back to his proper best for this season.  Next season maybe.  He is a great ruckman, but I think the back issues he has is a great concern.  I honestly can't see him averaging 85-90+ for the rest of the season.

[yorgis]

Aaaaargh !!!! maybe just see WHO plays this week and HOW they play. postpone trade till next week. need the cash to

upgrade treloar/porps and clarke

[powersuperkents]

I reckon Kruzer he's pretty useless when he's playing (DT wise comment) and you would make so much more money with that downgrade to Campbell. I honestly rank Redden higher in JS (if there has been any breaking news on injuries and teams regard this comment)

[yorgis]

you rank reddens js higher than kruzer ??? lobbe 's almost ready to come back. played in sanfl and did well

[fertalong]

Mumford tbh, though you would be left very short in the ruck department.  I started with Mummy and he gave me nothing but donuts early on.  I also wouldn't trust his on going back issues.

+1
Giles is a safer option than mummy and mummy really wont score that much more than him. If you are looking to make the trade this week, then I would say mummy.
If you can afford to wait a few weeks, you will be able to make a better decision based on their performances.

[danger]

Mummy's back will destroy you if you hang onto him.. But if you need cash and are looking to downgrade someone.. well, your rucks are screwed.  :-\

[DT Gun]

Mumford isn't fit