The upgrade - A toss of the coin.

[yogi82]

Due to some silly trading early on I need to have two of the following three as keepers? Help!

1. Marty Clarke
2. Giles
3. Treloar

I have 5 trades left.

My team is:
B: Deledio, Goddard, Waters, Hanley, Adcock, H Shaw, Clarke - Ellis, Townsend
M: Stanton, Ablett, Swan, Rockliff, Shane Tuck, Priddis - Shiel, Gibson
R: Cox, Giles
F: Franklin, Beams, Robinson, T Cloke, Adams, Treloar, Zorko - Sexton, Paine

[KoopKicka]

Giles and Treloar.

[andyandy89]

Giles & Treloar I think, but Clarke should play all games

[andyandy89]

Actually, i would suggest keeping Clarke and rotating him and Ellis as your last defender.

Your forward line is the weak link and you should maybe look into upgrading a forward or two

[jabroni]

id be getting one of treloar or adams traded out firstly - to sidey if u have cash otherwise danger or chappy

[Zombie2.5]

I'd say Clarke would be the on to get rid of (Carrazzo ideal)

BUT with your weak forwards, they're probably the first priority. Adams/Treloar are first to go. You could downgrade Shiel?

[fertalong]

Actually, i would suggest keeping Clarke and rotating him and Ellis as your last defender.

Your forward line is the weak link and you should maybe look into upgrading a forward or two

+1
Keep all 3 and go Adams to premo. Sidebum or Chappy would be best.

[Ash A]

keep giles and clarke :)

[azza707]

Keep clarke i would say. Collingwood finally have Toovey, Maxwell, Tarrant (should play this week) Reid all playing in the same side which is why i bought in heath shaw for the run home. Clarke should be able to roam free.
and while imo i think giles is going to go downhill from here with brogan in the side i think you're forced to keep him.

Maybe look at upgrading treloar to one of pav/stanley as they are only around 415k and save the cash left over for the finals

[Ricochet]

Actually, i would suggest keeping Clarke and rotating him and Ellis as your last defender.

Your forward line is the weak link and you should maybe look into upgrading a forward or two

+1 yeh need to strengthen that forward line mate. Clarke and Ellis have great JS so they're the least of your worries atm