Who should I get? (Cheers for help)

Started by nrich102, June 26, 2012, 07:06:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should I trade oldMac for?

Mitchell
3 (16.7%)
Redden
4 (22.2%)
Brad Ebert
5 (27.8%)
Carrots
3 (16.7%)
Other (please say below)
3 (16.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Voting closed: July 01, 2012, 07:06:18 AM

nrich102

My Team
Backs
Deledio, Goddard,H Shaw, Broughton, Hargrave, Johnson, Waters(S Shaw, Darley)
Mids
Thompson, Jellwood, Ablett, Rocky, Swan, OldMac (Gibson, Sexton)
Rucks
Jacobs, Giles (Stephenson, Redden)
Fowards
Sidebut, Beams, Chapman, Danger, Buddy, Robinson, Zorko,(Treloar , Folau)
Leaning towards Mitchell or Redden at this stage
Done Orren --> T Campbell that leaves me with 5 trades and $207,100.

Cheers If you comment

Cheers

its me lads

Redden is your best choice (accidentally voted for Ebert). Redden is in ripping form and he cant be tagged, people always tag Rockliff or Rich, Redden gets away and tackles so much that's how he gets points, he does also get the footy, not massive disposal numbers but can get big DT points. I brought him in 2 weeks ago, he got me 95 the 125. Absolute gun you cant tag someone who tackles.
1.Redden
2.Ebert
3.Mitchell

ALTHOUGH, if you can afford Swan, then get Swan :)

nrich102

Quote from: its me lads on June 26, 2012, 09:11:33 AM
Redden is your best choice (accidentally voted for Ebert). Redden is in ripping form and he cant be tagged, people always tag Rockliff or Rich, Redden gets away and tackles so much that's how he gets points, he does also get the footy, not massive disposal numbers but can get big DT points. I brought him in 2 weeks ago, he got me 95 the 125. Absolute gun you cant tag someone who tackles.
1.Redden
2.Ebert
3.Mitchell

ALTHOUGH, if you can afford Swan, then get Swan :)
I already have swan
Thanks anyway Jacko

nostradamus

of those mentioned it has to be Redden, but if you wait a few weeks can you afford Pendles when he bottoms out?

Ricochet

Quote from: nostradamus on June 26, 2012, 09:53:58 AM
of those mentioned it has to be Redden, but if you wait a few weeks can you afford Pendles when he bottoms out?
+1 of the ones above, Redden is the most consistent.
But with Pendles BE of 180 and Jmac having a lowish BE of 45, i'd be holding out for Pendles

stalker

Quote from: Ricochet on June 26, 2012, 10:07:50 AM
Quote from: nostradamus on June 26, 2012, 09:53:58 AM
of those mentioned it has to be Redden, but if you wait a few weeks can you afford Pendles when he bottoms out?
+1 of the ones above, Redden is the most consistent.
But with Pendles BE of 180 and Jmac having a lowish BE of 45, i'd be holding out for Pendles

+1

Colliwobblers

wait for pendles or even better Boyd, boyd will crash in price over the next two weeks and is a DT GUN.

makita

id hang out for another week and get on Kennedy, has slowed up a little but gets so much contested ball and sydney look to be playing a lost faster game this year. other than him i would wait and get pendles. team is looking pretty solid tho.

its me lads

Quote from: nrich102 on June 26, 2012, 09:48:08 AM
Quote from: its me lads on June 26, 2012, 09:11:33 AM
Redden is your best choice (accidentally voted for Ebert). Redden is in ripping form and he cant be tagged, people always tag Rockliff or Rich, Redden gets away and tackles so much that's how he gets points, he does also get the footy, not massive disposal numbers but can get big DT points. I brought him in 2 weeks ago, he got me 95 the 125. Absolute gun you cant tag someone who tackles.
1.Redden
2.Ebert
3.Mitchell

ALTHOUGH, if you can afford Swan, then get Swan :)
I already have swan
Thanks anyway Jacko

sorry forgot to check that. Redden is a gun, Mitchell gets tagged every week and Ebert doesnt have as high of a roof as reddo

Scrads

As mentioned, get in Pendles or Boyd in the coming weeks, but in the meantime swap Hargrave for Carrazzo (next week)

henry

Quote from: Scrads on June 26, 2012, 11:41:21 AM
As mentioned, get in Pendles or Boyd in the coming weeks, but in the meantime swap Hargrave for Carrazzo (next week)
+1, that looks like the best plan of action.

SydneyRox

Sound advice above. If you can afford to wait for Pendles then do it.

Dave085

As mentioned above, definately Pendlebury or Boyd. Hard to choose between the 2, but just be patient and you can get one of those 2 guns.

Aaron8

get in boyd he will bounce back this week with 120+ and you'll have a really solid mid

powersuperkents

Get Boyd, Jobe Watson or Stanton but if you can't afford them go Carrots hes cheap and he averages 103 if you exclude his score of 1. I just traded him into my backline over Heath Scotland this week whilst upgrading Hargrave