Rate your trades!

[Jroo]

Rate your sc trades!
Green= Good Orange= Average Red= Bad
Mine are:
ROUND 13
OUT   Hanley ($432,000)   IN   Crozier ($106,600)
OUT   Treloar ($346,100)   IN   Swan ($637,000)
OUT   Ellis ($257,200)   IN   Waters ($528,700)
ROUND 12
OUT   Sandilands ($481,200)   IN   Goldstein ($497,200)
OUT   Clarke ($361,200)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)
ROUND 11
OUT   Smith ($311,300)   IN   Birchall ($467,300)
OUT   Horsley ($324,600)   IN   Williams ($94,700)
ROUND 9
OUT   Magner ($311,800)   IN   Dal Santo ($481,900)
OUT   Hall ($177,500)   IN   Dangerfield ($560,600)
ROUND 8
OUT   Bugg ($335,600)   IN   Spurr ($116,700)
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)
ROUND 7
OUT   Kennedy ($229,000)   IN   Horsley ($128,700)
OUT   Goodes ($552,700)   IN   Beams ($511,700)
ROUND 5
OUT   Ledger ($113,200)   IN   Treloar ($113,200)
ROUND 4
OUT   Mumford ($610,300)   IN   Sandilands ($602,800)
ROUND 3
OUT   Paine ($106,600)   IN   Kennedy ($113,200

[nostradamus]

out of curiosity......what is your current team?

[Jay]

Rate your sc trades!
Green= Good Orange= Average Red= Bad
Mine are:
ROUND 13
OUT   Hanley ($432,000)   IN   Crozier ($106,600)
OUT   Treloar ($346,100)   IN   Swan ($637,000)
OUT   Ellis ($257,200)   IN   Waters ($528,700)
ROUND 12
OUT   Sandilands ($481,200)   IN   Goldstein ($497,200)
OUT   Clarke ($361,200)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)
ROUND 11
OUT   Smith ($311,300)   IN   Birchall ($467,300)
OUT   Horsley ($324,600)   IN   Williams ($94,700)
ROUND 9
OUT   Magner ($311,800)   IN   Dal Santo ($481,900)
OUT   Hall ($177,500)   IN   Dangerfield ($560,600)
ROUND 8
OUT   Bugg ($335,600)   IN   Spurr ($116,700)
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)
ROUND 7
OUT   Kennedy ($229,000)   IN   Horsley ($128,700)
OUT   Goodes ($552,700)   IN   Beams ($511,700)
ROUND 5
OUT   Ledger ($113,200)   IN   Treloar ($113,200)
ROUND 4
OUT   Mumford ($610,300)   IN   Sandilands ($602,800)
ROUND 3
OUT   Paine ($106,600)   IN   Kennedy ($113,200

Hanley > Crozier should be red mate! Hanley scored 110 more than Crozier this week lol

[Jroo]

out of curiosity......what is your current team?

B: Lids, Goddard, Birchall, Lake, Broughton, Waters, S.Shaw (Spurr, Smedts)
M: Ablett, Swan, Pendles, Priddis, Dal Santo, Sloane (Williams, JMac)
R: Goldstein, Giles (Orren, Redden)
F: Buddy, Sidey, Beams, Martin, Pav, Zorko, Danger (Dickson, Crozier)

[Jroo]

Rate your sc trades!
Green= Good Orange= Average Red= Bad
Mine are:
ROUND 13
OUT   Hanley ($432,000)   IN   Crozier ($106,600)
OUT   Treloar ($346,100)   IN   Swan ($637,000)
OUT   Ellis ($257,200)   IN   Waters ($528,700)
ROUND 12
OUT   Sandilands ($481,200)   IN   Goldstein ($497,200)
OUT   Clarke ($361,200)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)
ROUND 11
OUT   Smith ($311,300)   IN   Birchall ($467,300)
OUT   Horsley ($324,600)   IN   Williams ($94,700)
ROUND 9
OUT   Magner ($311,800)   IN   Dal Santo ($481,900)
OUT   Hall ($177,500)   IN   Dangerfield ($560,600)
ROUND 8
OUT   Bugg ($335,600)   IN   Spurr ($116,700)
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)
ROUND 7
OUT   Kennedy ($229,000)   IN   Horsley ($128,700)
OUT   Goodes ($552,700)   IN   Beams ($511,700)
ROUND 5
OUT   Ledger ($113,200)   IN   Treloar ($113,200)
ROUND 4
OUT   Mumford ($610,300)   IN   Sandilands ($602,800)
ROUND 3
OUT   Paine ($106,600)   IN   Kennedy ($113,200

Hanley > Crozier should be red mate! Hanley scored 110 more than Crozier this week lol

Yer but in the long run should be a good trade

[creeker]

Know when to hold em. Know when to fold em.

Currently top 1000, with 8 vital trades left.

Round 3    Coniglio  191600  -   Hayes   422000
Round 4    Hale   417500   -   M Johnson   414700
Round 5    Mumford   610300   -    Maric   382100  ( injury but a good fluke )
                Kennedy   219600    -    Barlow   444800
Round 6    Fyfe   484500   -   Sidebottom   491400  ( injury trade )
Round 7    Goodes    552700    -   N Riewoldt   479400  ( injury trade )
Round 8    Shiel    308200   -   Zaharakis   483300
                Bugg    335600   -   Spurr    116700  ( Grrrrr )
Round 9    Magner   311800    -    Zorko    113200
Round 10  Morris     288000    -    Darley    113200
Round 12  Hall    239300    -    Tex Walker    466900
               Spurr    162500   -    S Shaw    113200
               Hampton    199200    -    Priddis    464500
Round 13  Ellis    257200    -    Adcock    458800
               D Smith    292500    -    Crozier    106600
               Zaharakis     516300    -    Pavlich    482600   (  injury trade  )

Can sit tight for awhile now with only a few upgrades to go,  Dempsey, Barlow and Giles at some stage.

Current team
Backs    Deliedio,  Goddard,  H Shaw,  M Johnson,  Adcock,  Lake,  Dempsey.  ( Darley,  S Shaw )
Mids      Ablett,  Swan,  J Selwood,  Priddis,  Hayes,  Barlow,   ( J Mac,  Crozier  )
Ruck     Maric,  Giles,  ( Reddan,  Big O )
Fow      Franklin,  Sidebottom,  Dangerfield,  N Riewoldt,  Pavlich,  Walker,  Martin.  ( Zorko,  Smedts )     

6 trades in the last 2 weeks had to be done for byes but hopefully pays off.         

[quinny88]

bugg > spurr would have to be red wouldnt it?

[creeker]

Yeah Quinny, Wasn't the best move but did make me $45000 and helped me get Priddis.
Shame, I really rate Spurr, pity Ross Lyon doesn't.

[littleblueboy2906]

ROUND 12
OUT   Kennedy ($230,600)   IN   Tippett ($467,300)
OUT   Morris ($286,200)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)
OUT   Horsley ($324,600)   IN   Priddis ($464,500)
ROUND 11
OUT   McDonald ($310,000)   IN   Sexton ($128,800)
ROUND 10
OUT   Murphy ($505,600)   IN   Beams ($546,800)
OUT   Bugg ($320,800)   IN   Enright ($466,600)
ROUND 9
OUT   Magner ($311,800)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)
OUT   Swan ($634,500)   IN   Ablett ($708,500)
ROUND 8
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)   IN   Boyd ($566,300)
OUT   Kreuzer ($405,400)   IN   Campbell ($94,700)
ROUND 7
OUT   Goodes ($552,700)   IN   Zaharakis ($448,200)
OUT   Wingard ($182,200)   IN   Horsley ($128,700) should not of started with Wingard
ROUND 6
OUT   Smith ($223,700)   IN   Sidebottom ($491,400)
OUT   Ablett ($721,400)   IN   Pendlebury ($613,700)
ROUND 5
OUT   Smith ($155,300)   IN   McDonald ($106,600) should not of started with Clay!
OUT   Yarran ($416,600)   IN   Malceski ($411,100) WOW
ROUND 4
OUT   Fyfe ($528,600)   IN   Harvey ($547,700) :( hasn't been GREAT since coming in!
ROUND 3
OUT   Dickson ($106,600)   IN   Milera ($124,700)
OUT   Mumford ($610,300)   IN   Kreuzer ($418,300




Some really bad trades there, wasn't even thinking just kept doing 2 and 2 and 2 trades every week, now down to 2 :(

[fever]

only one i really dislike of mine was hall--> smedts when smedts was on his bubble.

[brownmans muffins]

ROUND 13
OUT Treloar ($346,100) IN Cloke ($396,600)
OUT Horsley ($321,600) IN Priddis ($507,900) missed lockout cost me 40K
ROUND 12
OUT Sandilands ($481,200) IN Goldstein ($497,200) missed lockout was meant to be NicNat
OUT Morris ($286,200) IN Shaw ($113,200) probably should've cut Townsend instead
ROUND 11
OUT Smith ($311,300) IN Ablett ($685,100) one week too late; the GAJ in/out was poor
ROUND 9
OUT Magner ($311,800) IN Zorko ($113,200)
OUT Bugg ($335,600) IN Dal Santo ($481,900)
ROUND 8
OUT Porplyzia ($342,100) IN Zaharakis ($483,300) went Zaha instead of Chappy
ROUND 7
OUT Goodes ($552,700) IN Riewoldt ($479,400)
OUT Kennedy ($229,000) IN Horsley ($128,700)
ROUND 6
OUT Dickson ($106,600) IN Riewoldt ($358,700)
OUT Fyfe ($484,500) IN Sidebottom ($491,400) one week too late - thought Fyfe would man up
ROUND 5
OUT Ablett ($721,400) IN Ward ($538,700) FML what was I thinking. Went Ward > Rockliff > Thompson
OUT Mumford ($610,300) IN McIntosh ($432,300) Hold judgement until HMac is back - have had adequate cover.
ROUND 4
OUT Smith ($155,300) IN Treloar ($113,200) Needed Treloar. Clay needed to go.
ROUND 3
OUT Cox ($662,600) IN Sandilands ($600,500) FML
OUT Broughton ($502,100) IN Dempsey ($273,800) starting to break even now

[dickitch]

ROUND 13
OUT   Zaharakis ($516,300)   IN   Beams ($601,100)
OUT   Smith ($292,500)   IN   Crozier ($106,600) - Yet to be proven, but this was a total cash cow trade, so it stays green
ROUND 12
OUT   Townsend ($199,500)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)
OUT   Magner ($298,200)   IN   Priddis ($464,500)
ROUND 10
OUT   Milera ($284,600)   IN   Dal Santo ($501,300)
OUT   Morris ($288,000)   IN   Darley ($113,200)
ROUND 9
OUT   Smedts ($155,200)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)
OUT   Murphy ($505,600)   IN   Waters ($493,400)
ROUND 8
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)   IN   Hale ($414,900)
OUT   Bugg ($335,600)   IN   Spurr ($116,700)  - terrible week of trades, had a grand plan involving Hale's DPP but never eventuated meaning i got me a pretty rubbish F - as for Spurr , pffft
ROUND 7
OUT   Kennedy ($229,000)   IN   Adams ($136,600)
ROUND 6
OUT   Fyfe ($484,500)   IN   Sidebottom ($491,400)
ROUND 5
OUT   Smith ($155,300)   IN   Treloar ($113,200)
ROUND 3
OUT   Dickson ($106,600)   IN   Milera ($124,700)
OUT   Broughton ($502,100)   IN   Dempsey ($273,800) - not red based on the money i gained, making it much easier to mess with team
ROUND 2
OUT   Gray ($490,100)   IN   Zaharakis ($494,100)

[EZA100]

ROUND 13
OUT   Sandilands ($481,200)   IN   Jacobs ($462,400)sandilands got injured
OUT   Morris ($286,200)   IN   Crozier ($106,600)
ROUND 11
OUT   Giles ($443,200)   IN   Sandilands ($541,300)rushed trade thats what stuffed up my trades :(
OUT   Smith ($311,300)   IN   Ablett ($685,100)smith was playing bad and i had to get ablett back into my team
OUT   Bugg ($318,000)   IN   Shaw ($113,200)bugg wasn't doing good and he dropped in price
ROUND 10
OUT   Coniglio ($352,000)   IN   Cotchin ($541,800)coniglio had a bad game but i guess it wasn't a bad trade because he did end up getting injured
OUT   Malceski ($366,900)   IN   Enright ($466,600)malceski wasn't doing good.
ROUND 9
OUT   Murphy ($505,600)   IN   Zorko ($113,200)murphy got injured
ROUND 8
OUT   Porplyzia ($342,100)   IN   Boyd ($566,300)porplyzia wasn't do that good
OUT   Leuenberger ($498,100)   IN   Jenkins ($113,200)leuenberger was injured he was on my bench so got over 300k for him
ROUND 7
OUT   Redden ($455,100)   IN   Sidebottom ($513,800)
OUT   Houli ($470,900)   IN   Deledio ($584,900)houli didn't have form i don't know why i didn't put deledio into my team at the start. :(
ROUND 6
OUT   Gunston ($277,100)   IN   Goddard ($539,600)gunston didn't play at all had one alright game
OUT   Ablett ($721,400)   IN   Pendlebury ($613,700)ablett got injured
ROUND 5
OUT   Patton ($196,600)   IN   Treloar ($113,200)quickly had to finish my team so just got patton.
OUT   Tyson ($186,600)   IN   McDonald ($106,600)forgot about getting him in and tyson has really been playing
ROUND 4
OUT   Shaw ($516,300)   IN   Johnson ($414,700)shaw got injured
OUT   Brown ($106,600)   IN   Bugg ($187,100)brown hasn't played a game played in nab cub
ROUND 3
OUT   Barlow ($453,600)   IN   Murphy ($639,900)barlow was sub twice a waste of a trade not fully needed
OUT   Palmer ($355,300)   IN   Magner ($94,700)palmer got 126 first round then did bad so got in magner
ROUND 2
OUT   Zorko ($113,200)   IN   Porplyzia ($229,600)didn't play for a while didn't look into what happened to him
OUT   Weedon ($113,200)   IN   Kennedy ($113,200)hasn't played a game didn't look into him

so annoyed i didn't research into who was playing and who wasn't left my team to the last minute literally didn't get goddard,deledio,pendlebury,swan. left with two trades and 3 upgrades you do the math  ::)

[Tainey]

ROUND 13
OUT   Kennedy ($230,600)    IN   Gibson ($94,700)
ROUND 11
OUT   McDonald ($310,000)    IN   Kennedy ($593,700)
OUT   Pendlebury ($620,400)   IN   Johnson  ($479,500) Waste of a trade having brought Pendles in a few weeks earlier
OUT   Townsend ($199,500)    IN   Shaw ($113,200) Shaw hasn't scored too well and is now injured
ROUND 10
OUT   Bugg ($320,800)    IN   Darley ($113,200)
ROUND 9
OUT   Ebert ($482,900)    IN   Thompson ($633,400)
OUT   Porplyzia ($348,200)    IN   Waters ($493,400)
ROUND 8
OUT   Shiel ($308,200)    IN   Pendlebury ($636,900) Only had Pendles for 2/3 games before he was injured
OUT   Geary ($298,100)    IN   Zorko ($113,200) Geary made me about 80K and had started to score poorly so his job was done
ROUND 7
OUT   Goodes ($552,700)    IN   Sidebottom ($513,800)
OUT   Magner ($280,600)    IN   Horsley ($128,700)
ROUND 5
OUT   Smith ($155,300)    IN   Treloar ($113,200) Happy to get rid of Clay
ROUND 4
OUT   Fyfe ($528,600)    IN   Harvey ($547,700) Boomer has scored poorly since I got him in - could have chosen Beams/Dangerfield/Sidey for less $$
OUT   Mumford ($610,300)    IN   Naitanui ($513,800)
ROUND 3
OUT   Coniglio ($191,600)    IN   Ebert ($344,400)
OUT   Broughton ($502,100)    IN   Geary ($213,000)

[dickitch]

Shaw hasn't scored too well and is now injured

waaaaa, hadn't seen that til now!!  :(