Need to make a big call re trades this week

[whorya]

Hi all....got a big decidsion to make with trades

looking at donuts this week - 5-6 roughly (mainly in backs) which will improve with trades of course.

shoudl i go with a) or b)

a) out: treloar & Horse     in: Thomo & Gibbo

or

b) out jmac, Horse & Pendles      in: Thomo, Watson/Stanton & Gibbo

got 10 trades (pre trading) and not much cash 60k i think.

full team is

B: scotland, Gods, birch, Heppell, Waters, Hargrave, Shaw, Ellis, Smetz
C: Ablett, J.Selw, Boyd, Pendles, A.Swallow, Horse, Treloar, Jmac
R: Goldy, Ryder, Big O, Redden
F: Frank, Siddey, Robbo, Lewis, Pearce, Danger, Martin, Zorko, Adams

What would you do

Any other options ???

Im going for league - struggling at 5-5 with avg % and my oppo this week has similar donuts....4 i think

Cheers

[Dave085]

Sam Shaw or Heath Shaw in the backs?

Dont trade Pendles out. What about trading Horse/Treloar to Gibson and Hargrave to Johnson/Heath Shaw (If its sam in the backs already).

[Jericho500]

If going for league trade for final trades not to win this week. If it was my team I would be looking at trading Hargrave - trelor- horsley- j Mac - Pearce - Ellis smelts - Martin . That said look at these and see who you would keep. At three this week trade Hargrave to Johnson , horsley to Gibson  and pending how much money upgrade jmac or trelor?

[whorya]

sorry Sam Shaw

yeh not a bad option m johnson

i really wanted thomo from adelaide to complete my mids

would this work?

out horse, treloar and hargrave in gibbo, thomo and johnson work?

[whorya]

nah cant do that last one - 30k short!

[Dave085]

Youre going to get short on trades. Can you go Ellis to Johnson instead of Hargrave? You might have to consider keeping Hargrave and hoping he is a late inclusion this week.

You would want to aim for Swan in the mids. Be patient and make sure your rookies are maxed out and dont trade prematurely.

[whorya]

im going ellis to carrots next week or week after - so want to keep ellis for that. hargrave in is a big if....i really wanted to go treloar to thomo as he has maxed out but it doesnt improve my donut situation