1 has got to go!

Started by mzunguman, June 20, 2012, 10:20:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one should I trade?

Nick Malceski
14 (53.8%)
Marty Clarke
11 (42.3%)
Neither
1 (3.8%)

Total Members Voted: 1

mzunguman

Looking to get in Heppell to complete my backline!
Final Backs would look like
Deledio, Goddard, Hurn, Adcock, Johnson, Heppell, Clarke/Malceski, [S.Shaw, Ellis]
Thanks

Luigi197

Provided that this is the trade that you know you are going to make, I voted to get rid of Marty Clarke because Malceski has so much more evidence and history to prove that he can average like a premium, more than Clarke can.

SydneyRox

Really tough call.

Clarke is unlikely to score as well as Eski could, but Eski hasnt been the same player most of this year either.

My gut would normally back Eski to come good, I have been talking him up most of the season...

If he gets named, and doesnt get the vest on Friday then keep Eski.

HotTiges

this will be my thread next week Mzungu!! good luck with how you go.. I'm slightly leaning towards keeping Mal as he has the higher scorering potential..

Capper

i think Clarke has the better JS and will never be the sub or subbed

Rambo

Malceski has higher scoring potential than Clarke

PICCOLLO

Based on what we've seen this year, youd keep clarke.

pikla

Clarke is prob the safer option with better JS but I think there's a chance Malceski might come back in with a lot more urgency in his game after being dropped. I had him and pissed him off 2 weeks ago cause he just looked lazy, but yeah we could see a different attitude this week