Which Defenders

[mmurphy3]

My defence is Delidio, Shaw, Broughton, Birchall, Hargrave, Goddard Morris

Im upgrading Morris and im thinking of getting waters carrazzo or scotland but whats your thoughts??L

[Windigo]

Waters this week, or Carrazzo next week.

I'd just get in Waters and reap a nice solid score from him rather than wait a week.

[Mr.Craig]

I'll give you Hanley for free if you'd like.

[Gurans]

Waters this week, or Carrazzo the week after next week.

I'd just get in Waters and reap a nice solid score from him rather than wait a week.

+1 except need to wait two more for Carrazzo to drop in price again

[Jukes]

Can't go wrong with any of Waters, Scotland and Carrazzo.

Have had Waters all season, getting in the Carlton duo next week.

[DT Gun]

Carrazzo is over rated around here. Him Johnson waters Birchall all on par with each other

[pommyadam]

i voted for Scotland and Johnson
i quite like Johnson's consistency (seems to score regularly around the 90 mark) and Scotland's capable of those big scores

they're both DPP, which aids their case imo

[Mr.Craig]

Carrazzo is over rated around here. Him Johnson waters Birchall all on par with each other

In 2 weeks we can get a player who is averaging 104 (minus the injury game) at around 375k. If he's on par with those other players then why wouldn't you go with the guy who is 20k-50k cheaper?