who will round this midfield?

Started by DT-SC, June 20, 2012, 05:01:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

WHo

watson
14 (35%)
stanton
7 (17.5%)
selwood
0 (0%)
thompson
19 (47.5%)
other (specify)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 3

DT-SC

Swan, ablett, Pendles, Boyd, Rocky, ??  (treloer, sexton)
can afford anyone, was instantly on scotty T but remembered sanderson saying he would rest players, and with them versing Lions, Demons and Gary Ablett prior to the finals(DT finals) its slightly turned me off him
watson is a gun and will keep it up if he remains uninjured
stanton cant handle a tag very well
selwood is....selwood, great but not super great

leaning towards watson
Cheers

its me lads

it amazes me that so very few people reccomend stanton, he is averaging the third most out of everyone (123), he seems to be a very good pick and i dont know why you wouldnt get him......but in saying that....i dont have him. haha. i have thommo and watson :P.  they are all good options anyway.

Ziplock

because he's a flog and has a 3 round average of 96, including barely tonning up against melbourne, and only getting 90 odd vs the giants.

Windigo


aces-high

I would personally go watson. But thommo looked incredible on the weekend! Both play a similar role but the risk of thommo getting rested later on outweighs watto who as skipper will play week in week out. Gotta be watson! Teams have figured out stanton cant handle a tag and are letting jobe run free. Lock in watson :)

BB67th

I think you just have to go Watson. No real chance of him being rested and is a ball winning machine.

its me lads

Quote from: Ziplock on June 20, 2012, 06:04:44 PM
because he's a flog and has a 3 round average of 96, including barely tonning up against melbourne, and only getting 90 odd vs the giants.

if we want to talk about melbourne and GWS then Scott thompson only got 109 against GWS, Boyd only got 84 against melbourne, Watson only got 91 against GWS, selwood only managed 62 against GWS (injury effected but still played a full game), Ablett only got 106 against GWS.

Manbearpig

Work out which one of Stanton and Watson is going to get Crowleyed this week and pick the other one.

stew42

#8
Somehow I have this idea that Watson should be up for #1 tag every week over Watson...Stanton...


... I may be a bit drunk. Ignore me.

its me lads

Quote from: stew42 on June 20, 2012, 07:31:10 PM
Somehow I have this idea that Watson should be up for #1 tag every week over Watson...

lol

yorgis


stew42

Normally I'd rank them
1. Jelwood
2. Watson
3. Stanton
4. Scotty T

But with the draw the Crows have, Scotty T moves to #1. Even if he is rested once or even twice during the season, the 140+'s will be worth it.


Tominator

All wonderful options, consistency is the only issue there. You can't go wrong with any of them, so go with your gut!

Bak2Form

im going thompson, the 40k i save over watson is probably the number 1 factor as he is my last upgrade and dont want to waste a trade to get more $$. i think both will average similar for the remaining of the year. you have to love tomo's easy run home

Flame

I have Stanton and have been happy with his output. There is always a lot of hysteria about him though! I also have Thompson. I have had him from Rd 1 and he has been a great pick up.