Time's up for Big O/Redden???

[stalker]

Is it time to cash in Jarrad Redden or Orren Stephenson after the bye??

They both have a BE around 57-61 and personally I don't think they both can beat it...Infact I see Geelong dropping Big O for most of the remaining games...

But the question is who to bring in as emergencies as there's no potential downgrades??
I get a feeling that we will be stuck with these two for the rest of the year...

Any thoughts guys?

[Marcos83]

They havent made enough for me yet and when they get more game time and as a result more points then offload. However I'm sure you must have others in the mix that are rookies that you could trade first and upgrade elsewhere.

[Ricochet]

yeh haven't really made enough money to warrant a the use of a trade

[Turkies]

hold them.... seriously there is no point trading them, there are tons more rookies that you can get more cash from, e.g treloar, devon smith, horsely, 4fer, ect. keep them as back up, or upgrade one of them if you have a complete team and want a 3rd ruck for backup. until someone comes out as a downgrade target there is 0 point in trading

[Holz]

the only reason to get rid of one of them is if you have a premium giles ruck combo and you upgrade one of them to a cox, maric etc... and than put giles on the bench.

[stalker]

much appreciated!

[Scrads]

Or like me, trade one to Pattinson, 85k R/F so I can DPP with Roughead :)

[Holz]

Or like me, trade one to Pattinson, 85k R/F so I can DPP with Roughead :)

wish i could have joined you on that it was a smart move getting in roughy, if he wasnt round 13 I would have done the same.

[captain dt]

recken they will be good finals trades bring in maric for giles

[Dave085]

What about James Sellar? Not a great scorer but getting games and also priced at $186,500.

[captain dt]

recken they will be good finals trades bring in maric for giles

by the way,

new poll ;D

wooden spoon worst personality of fanfooty 2012

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,62701.0.html  ;D

[Justin Bieber]

Shut up captain dt.

[Football Factory]

Or like me, trade one to Pattinson, 85k R/F so I can DPP with Roughead :)

I got rid of H.Mac for Pattinson needed the cash to put Swanny in .. if i get an injury to one of my rucks ill upgrade Zorko/Martin to Roughy for cover

Keeping Redden no point trading

[Memphistopheles]

Just saw somewhere today that the Bulldogs were looking at upgrading Campbell with their rookie upgrade.

He would be the perfect downgrade choice.