Rate a team outta 10, close to final (gotta picture)

[TheHanger]

The team is set up as if there was no bye, and I believe only 3 trades required to finish it off, leaving 3 to cover injuries if I need
This week I have gone Horsley to Thompson



The trades I am looking to do are:

Adams -> Upgrade (move into forward line)
Smedts -> Downgrade
Treloar or Greene or Bugg -> (A better mid rookie, or Carrazzo)

[Andrew]

Gibson is your downgrade, Beams your upgrade. I wouldn't worry about the other trade you're considering - use the rest of your trades to upgrade Giles to Maric. Good luck, looking good.

[KoopKicka]

Gibson is your downgrade, Beams your upgrade. I wouldn't worry about the other trade you're considering - use the rest of your trades to upgrade Giles to Maric. Good luck, looking good.

Thatd be pointless when he has Hmac on the bench ::)

[Ash A]

Gibson is your downgrade, Beams your upgrade. I wouldn't worry about the other trade you're considering - use the rest of your trades to upgrade Giles to Maric. Good luck, looking good.

id reckon carrots would be nicer to have on field than dempsey... bugg --> carrazzo would be my advice and dempsey to the pine

[PowerBug]

Places left to upgrade: 2 forward, 1 backline (i don't like Dempsey)

Your next two trades should be:
Greene >> Gibson (Leaving ~$290k)
Adams (DPP with Treloar) >> Beams (As long as Beams is under $540000 at the time)

This leaves Giles and Zorko as your only playing rookies. You have HMac waiting (i presume you are keeping him) so only 1 come finals time with 4 trades left. Either Bugg/Dempsey >> Carrazzo in 2 weeks (Prior to Rd15) or an upgrade/downgrade of Zorko/Smedts/Treloar and get another premium and Couch.

Team should be fine if your premium stay clear of any trouble.

[TheHanger]

Gibson is your downgrade, Beams your upgrade. I wouldn't worry about the other trade you're considering - use the rest of your trades to upgrade Giles to Maric. Good luck, looking good.

would prefer to wait for a better rookie than Gibson, one of the essendon boys like Kavanagh or someone else like Couch, still 10 rounds left lots of good rookies to come

[PowerBug]

Gibson is your downgrade, Beams your upgrade. I wouldn't worry about the other trade you're considering - use the rest of your trades to upgrade Giles to Maric. Good luck, looking good.

would prefer to wait for a better rookie than Gibson, one of the essendon boys like Kavanagh or someone else like Couch, still 10 rounds left lots of good rookies to come

Well, i would take Gibson personally. Or if you want that DPP link go straight to Couch. ;)

[dtfreak]

Go dempsey to carrazzo, Taylor adams to gibson, then treloar to beams, johnson or goodes. Then your team is set and you have 3 trades left for injuries  :D

[TheHanger]

Go dempsey to carrazzo, Taylor adams to gibson, then treloar to beams, johnson or goodes. Then your team is set and you have 3 trades left for injuries  :D

that means keeping smedts