Which one for Hall

Started by Jormas, June 17, 2012, 08:18:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Last FWD bench keeper - choose one

Patton
9 (45%)
Crozier
6 (30%)
Black
2 (10%)
Other Rook???
3 (15%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jormas

Fwd Rook

Poll explains it all.

The It

I think Patton, he is a little more expensive but his JS is pretty much 100% being the number one draft pick. He will improve with every game he plays

Windigo

If $$$ isn't a worry.

Patton.

Jormas

the extra 80K is handy; have 135K, looking to go Hall -> one of those 2 this week.

Patton = 200K; Crozier = 280K

then Hayes to Thommo this week also = only 120K left.

The Hargrave -> Carrazo after rd.14 will cost about a 120K difference; will be cutting it fine, but then also want to do a final upgrade of Giles -> Maric/Mumford, might need to cull Smith -> Gibson after rd.13 then to get the $$ for it?

What do you think?

Windigo

In that case, get the cheaper option.  ;)

It's always good to think ahead with the trades. But even the best laid plans can be laid to waste.

Hargrave did everyone a favor (arguably) by not playing. He won't leak any cash this week.


Jormas

Quote from: Windigo on June 17, 2012, 08:34:31 PM
In that case, get the cheaper option.  ;)

It's always good to think ahead with the trades. But even the best laid plans can be laid to waste.

Hargrave did everyone a favor (arguably) by not playing. He won't leak any cash this week.


Really? i will still have to make the same amount of trades, by my calc. i will have enough $$ after the patton trade, to go Hayes -> Thommo and Hargraves to Carrots. then i will inevitably need to go Smith -> Gibson to do the Giles upgrade, i will not have enough money from the 80K i save from Patton to upgrade Giles to Maric (110K needed)

Patton has Better JS, but Crozier if he plays a full game, from what i have seen has better scoring capability.

twinkle

Just looked up Crozier in the player search - says 184cm and 68 kgs... surely that can't be right??

T Dog

simon black bye a mile   :o

Cicjose

Quote from: T Dog on June 17, 2012, 09:42:03 PM
simon black bye a mile   :o

i think he is referring to Aaron Black from the Kangaroos

T Dog