Cyril???

Started by Spinking, June 17, 2012, 03:08:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Spinking

Picked the 'delicious' one in my round 1 team after pre season reports had him playing more time in the guts. Now after byes he sits on the bench in my fwd line behind: Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Robbo, Dangerfield, Buddy, Zaha, Martin.  Also have Zorko and Treloar in the mids as backups.

Should I bite the bullet and trade him out after the byes and use the cash on my mids, sit him on the pine until later in the year, or look to trade another fwd - Zaha or Martin?

12 trades / $250k

masedog333

yeah trade him out to make some money- theres no point having 450-500K on ya bench

Capper

wouldnt you start cyril in front of Zaha????

Spinking

Quote from: tabs on June 17, 2012, 03:23:33 PM
wouldnt you start cyril in front of Zaha????
At the moment while injured Yes, but ordinarily No.

Zaharias fairly consistent 90 odd average, Cyril 80 odd average - can score anywhere from 50 to 120...

Blues17

Cyril better in SC then DT. Gets alot of contested stuff and 1%.

I would trade him out in DT though

disco1992

i'd keep he's doing okay today 98 is a good score

stew42

Quote from: masedog333 on June 17, 2012, 03:13:41 PM
yeah trade him out to make some money- theres no point having 450-500K on ya bench
+1. Trade out the guy in you fwds you like the least, and upgrade elsewhere. You have Zorko who is performing better atm than Cloke and Martin, and Treloar, well I won't say anything about him...

pommyadam

Quote from: stew42 on June 17, 2012, 06:14:01 PM
and Treloar, well I won't say anything about him...

hopefully he's just had a bad week
thought that T button looks so much more appealing than it did a week ago

Spinking

The appealing thing about a Treloar trade now is his BE. He will almost certainly go down now, is a nice healthy price and although he appears to be in GWS best 22 there are no guarantees up there. I'm thinking it might be time to pull the trigger.

pommyadam

Quote from: Spinking on June 17, 2012, 09:34:24 PM
The appealing thing about a Treloar trade now is his BE. He will almost certainly go down now, is a nice healthy price and although he appears to be in GWS best 22 there are no guarantees up there. I'm thinking it might be time to pull the trigger.

i would be, except i've got other areas to improve first
touch wood he scores well (i'll bail on him next week)

as to Rioli, he's too expensive for what he scores, there are better options out there
if he's just sitting on the bench, take him out and strengthen another area

DT Gun

Trade Cyril - premium mid

Switch Treloar forward