Ask Q (15/6/12)

[Master Q]

You know how it works ;) Ask me a question and I'll give you my honest opinion!

Deadline: 6:20 PM EST (sorry for the shortness)

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

Edit: I almost forgot! If you have twitter, make sure to follow OurAFL - ask me a question and you should get a reply ASAP!  :)

[Master Q]

no one?

[Juddster5]

What do you think of trading Lee Spurr out for Sam Shaw? Saves a 0.

[lollipop man]

Ablett or Boyd captain?

[Thunderstruck]

Q - are you bringing in Sam Gibson before lockout or gonna hold and see how he does 1st?

If your holding is he on your radar to bring into your side?

[Tominator]

Morris to Shaw gives me $154,000 in the bank, then trading Magner to Gibson gives me $354,000

Should I use that cash to upgrade Stephenson to Maric? That would leave me with  $92,700 and 8 trades
Currently have Giles, Redden and HMac

Thanks Q

[Blairholt]

ive got cox, sandilands, redden and stepenson - can afford sandi > anyone what do u think?

[stew42]

Well, if you're bored, I'll show you my team and some plans I have...

TEAM NAME: Evil Weevils CASH LEFT: $51,300
DEF: B. Deledio, B. Goddard, G. Birchall, R. Hargrave, B. Ellis, S. Darley, S. Shaw (M. Clarke, H. Shaw)
MID: M. Boyd, S. Mitchell, S. Thompson, M. Priddis, D. Smith, J. McDonald (D. Swan, S. Pendlebury)
RUC: J. Giles, S. Jacobs (O. Stephenson, S. Mumford)
FWD: L. Franklin, P. Chapman, P. Dangerfield, D. Martin, A. Treloar, A. Hall, D. Zorko (S. Sidebottom, T. Couch)

In two weeks I'll drop one of JMac and DSmith for Sam Gibson, this will let me trade in Carrots for hopefully Ellis, but if not, Clarke.

I'm happy atm with my mids and rucks (Priddis will be upgraded near season's end), but my fwds are really disappointing me. I reckon I'll need to upgrade/cull Hall, Couch and maybe Treloar. All sound good?

[Tominator]

Ablett or Boyd captain?

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,62384.0.html

[stew42]

ive got cox, sandilands, redden and stepenson - can afford sandi > anyone what do u think?

Maric is the best option, if you want to ignore the byes.
Q, you can take it from here  ;D

[Master Q]

What do you think of trading Lee Spurr out for Sam Shaw? Saves a 0.

Only if you plenty of trades and are getting many donuts this week.

Ablett or Boyd captain?

Toughy but I actually think Boyd is the better option.

[Master Q]

Q - are you bringing in Sam Gibson before lockout or gonna hold and see how he does 1st?

If your holding is he on your radar to bring into your side?

No... My backline is set anyway.

Morris to Shaw gives me $154,000 in the bank, then trading Magner to Gibson gives me $354,000

Should I use that cash to upgrade Stephenson to Maric? That would leave me with  $92,700 and 8 trades
Currently have Giles, Redden and HMac

Thanks Q

I'm not sure about Magner to Gibson, any other options? I like Morris to Shaw - could you do Hmac--> Ruck?

[stew42]

Q - are you bringing in Sam Gibson before lockout or gonna hold and see how he does 1st?

If your holding is he on your radar to bring into your side?

No... My backline is set anyway.

How about your mids?

[MTTY]

Thoughts on Deledio captain this week Q? 140 against GWS pre-season coming off a hamstring injury.

[Master Q]

ive got cox, sandilands, redden and stepenson - can afford sandi > anyone what do u think?

Maric  :)

Q - are you bringing in Sam Gibson before lockout or gonna hold and see how he does 1st?

If your holding is he on your radar to bring into your side?

No... My backline is set anyway.

How about your mids?

Whoops... Typo  :P  ;) I'm not so sure atm but if he performs he could be a possible downgrade