Fallen V Rising

[mzunguman]

Which one to pick? Puopolo proved last year what he is capable of and has scored 80 and 93 in his past two games - but. is he carrying an injury or sub prone?

Sam Shaw is cheap and many people are thinking his JS is reasonably good. Averaging 74 but don't really know to much about him

If i trade one of these in i plan on keeping them for the rest of the season although Puopolo doesn't fit my structure amazingly but i could make it work

Thanks

[Bennyy]

Shaw for sure for me, pardon the pun.
You make an extra 150k or so? And I beleive Shaw is more than capable as a solid D8, and fits in with the byes nicely. Has been spoken about a lot on here, but the coach seems to like him and has been getting picked ahead of Otten and Henderson. Ive brought him in myself this week, hopefully not famous last words!

[mzunguman]

Shaw for sure for me, pardon the pun.
You make an extra 150k or so? And I beleive Shaw is more than capable as a solid D8, and fits in with the byes nicely. Has been spoken about a lot on here, but the coach seems to like him and has been getting picked ahead of Otten and Henderson. Ive brought him in myself this week, hopefully not famous last words!

you are right in saying about the extra cash will help me for later rounds etc
But whose to say if Shaw plays one dud game - gets dropped and we never see him again?
Although saying that, I'm pretty sure puopolo has been carrying a niggling injury all season so he would be a risk

[Bennyy]

Yeah exactly, he might throw in some stinkers and get dropped, but Puopolo could do the same thing, hawks got a lot of talent in the small forwards, Gunston will be trying to hold his spot he is a bit taller. And Puopolo id say is definitely more sub prone. Theres arguements either way but for the extra 150k you get in your pocket i think Shaw is the one you should get!

[mzunguman]

Yeah the poll speaks for itself really - sam shaw it is!