Ask Holzman Round 12

[Alka]

Holz, should I get rid of Morris instead of Clarke now that he's injured?

[Holz]

Holz, should I get rid of Morris instead of Clarke now that he's injured?

yes its what im doing. Will save you a donut next week.

[pinochio]

12 trades and 18k left!

morris > sam shaw
horsely > priddis
whiteX > dangerfield

OR

morris > sam shaw
horsely > priddis
clarke > adcock

all rd 13 saying goodbye....miniising donuts of next round

9 trades left

thoughts mate?

[essendon2]

Clarke --> S.Shaw
Sexton --> Gibson
Morris --> Adcock

Next week:
Milera --> Crozier
McDonald --> Swan
Ellis --> M.Johnson

[Alka]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

[Holz]

12 trades and 18k left!

morris > sam shaw
horsely > priddis
whiteX > dangerfield

OR

morris > sam shaw
horsely > priddis
clarke > adcock

all rd 13 saying goodbye....miniising donuts of next round

9 trades left

thoughts mate?

the first one by a mile.

[Holz]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

If it saves a donut than i can see a reason to get rid of them. i would try and get rid of others first but if they are going to give you a donut next week there is nothing wrong with droping them now.

I thought they were both safe but GC made abucnh of changes and that seems to be what they do so who knows if they will be back. I wouldnt want to rely on them but they are ok to sit last on your bench.

[Lucastorm]

How do I delete my dream team?

[essendon2]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

If it saves a donut than i can see a reason to get rid of them. i would try and get rid of others first but if they are going to give you a donut next week there is nothing wrong with droping them now.

I thought they were both safe but GC made abucnh of changes and that seems to be what they do so who knows if they will be back. I wouldnt want to rely on them but they are ok to sit last on your bench.

Get rid of Smedts or Sexton?
Sexton right? Because at least Smedts has a chance of playing next week

[elephants]

Okay, currently have 3 donuts (Beams, Pendles and Hall).

Really pissed with Hall, Smedts and Giles.

Giles -> Goldstein
Smedts -> Sam Shaw
Hall -> O'Hanlon!!! :o

Would leave me with 6 trades and 360k.

Would then plan for moves like Conca to Heppell/Shaw/Broughton/Waters and Ellis to Heppell/Shaw/Broughton/Waters and then Treloar to Swanny ;D

Doing these trades would leave me with 2-3 trades left :X

Halp!!

[Holz]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

If it saves a donut than i can see a reason to get rid of them. i would try and get rid of others first but if they are going to give you a donut next week there is nothing wrong with droping them now.

I thought they were both safe but GC made abucnh of changes and that seems to be what they do so who knows if they will be back. I wouldnt want to rely on them but they are ok to sit last on your bench.

Get rid of Smedts or Sexton?
Sexton right? Because at least Smedts has a chance of playing next week

yeah sexton but i dont think smedts will play next week and i think sexton is more likely to play. Depends a little on the downgrade target for sexton you go gibson and for smedts you go shaw or gibson. Probably play it safe and drop sexton.

[Holz]

Okay, currently have 3 donuts (Beams, Pendles and Hall).

Really pissed with Hall, Smedts and Giles.

Giles -> Goldstein
Smedts -> Sam Shaw
Hall -> O'Hanlon!!! :o

Would leave me with 6 trades and 360k.

Would then plan for moves like Conca to Heppell/Shaw/Broughton/Waters and Ellis to Heppell/Shaw/Broughton/Waters and then Treloar to Swanny ;D

Doing these trades would leave me with 2-3 trades left :X

Halp!!

dont do hall to ohanlon, can you get in gibson instead, he at least is a chance to play all year. I would keep giles to be honest and take the donut 2-3 trades is not much, especially with another bye coming up.

[essendon2]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

If it saves a donut than i can see a reason to get rid of them. i would try and get rid of others first but if they are going to give you a donut next week there is nothing wrong with droping them now.

I thought they were both safe but GC made abucnh of changes and that seems to be what they do so who knows if they will be back. I wouldnt want to rely on them but they are ok to sit last on your bench.

Get rid of Smedts or Sexton?
Sexton right? Because at least Smedts has a chance of playing next week

yeah sexton but i dont think smedts will play next week and i think sexton is more likely to play. Depends a little on the downgrade target for sexton you go gibson and for smedts you go shaw or gibson. Probably play it safe and drop sexton.

well Sexton has bye next week, so it'd be a definite zero.
unless he's a late inclusion this week???

Definitely going Clarke --> Shaw

but then trades 2 and 3 and screwing my head: Sexton/Smedts --> Gibson

3: either Morris --> Adcock or Giles --> Goldstein

[Holz]

is it too early to off-load Sexton? Same with Hall?

They both have a lot of cash to make. Do you think they'll make it back in the team?
Hall costs me 2 donuts, Sexton just the one.

If it saves a donut than i can see a reason to get rid of them. i would try and get rid of others first but if they are going to give you a donut next week there is nothing wrong with droping them now.

I thought they were both safe but GC made abucnh of changes and that seems to be what they do so who knows if they will be back. I wouldnt want to rely on them but they are ok to sit last on your bench.

Get rid of Smedts or Sexton?
Sexton right? Because at least Smedts has a chance of playing next week

yeah sexton but i dont think smedts will play next week and i think sexton is more likely to play. Depends a little on the downgrade target for sexton you go gibson and for smedts you go shaw or gibson. Probably play it safe and drop sexton.

well Sexton has bye next week, so it'd be a definite zero.
unless he's a late inclusion this week???

Definitely going Clarke --> Shaw

but then trades 2 and 3 and screwing my head: Sexton/Smedts --> Gibson

3: either Morris --> Adcock or Giles --> Goldstein

sexton to gibson and morris to adcock, giles will play next week.

[Tominator]

hey Holzman

already traded Morris to Sam Shaw, so I have $154K in the bank with 10 trades left. Plan on making my next two:

1) Magner to Gibson (gives me $355K and covers one donut)
2) Stephenson to Maric (gives me $92K and covers another donut but one extra next week). Thinking of waiting until Rd 14

Should I do these trades this week or not?

Love your work Holz!


BTW I want to hold HMac so that when he comes back I'll have Maric, HMac (Giles, Redden)