Keepers???

[TheHanger]

Which (if any) of these blokes are keepers, also say where you think they would be on a team (i.e. 6th mid, 9th back) and whether they should be your premier rook (i.e. zorko as rook 7th fwd, or 8th fwd but no rookie in starting 7 fwds)

Courtney Dempsey - inconsistent but scored a few 90s and injury affected average

Dayne Zorko - gun

Toby Greene - fairly consistent, on the slide, can he stay good enough?

Tomas Bugg - on the slide, but good enough as a 9th back?

Kyal Horsley - showed us why he was so highly rated, but fallen off dramatically last two games before being 'rested'

Jonathon Giles - done awesome, good enough to remain second ruck?

Adam Treloar - inconsistent but can pull good scores

Billie Smedts - been awful, but gets games (sort of) and hasn't increased enough for a good cash boost

thoughts much appreciated

[its me lads]

Courtenay Dempsey: If you have a reasonable amount of trades left then trade him but i wouldnt be too worried if he was D7. He would be very safe D8 Bench cover aswell.

Dayne Zorko: Gun, But wouldnt want him on the field, he's a M/F 8 or 9. good bench cover with a good average.

Toby Greene: Not a keeper for me.

Tomas Bugg: Not a keeper unless he rebounds, if he does he will still only be D8 or 9

Kyal Horsely: Mos people have opted to trade him out, me included.

Jonathon Giles: He's a keeper for me but im currently deciding weather or not to bring in another premo ruck so i can sit him on the pine. If you have plenty of trades left then downgrade orren or redden and put giles on the pine as cover

Adam Treloar: IMO he would be suitable F 8 or 9 cover, should be able to step up if you need him.

Billie Smedts: Definately not a keeper but then again, not a whole lot of rookie defender are, still no chance of being a keeper.

[jmoynihan9]

Courtney Dempsey - potential to be your D7 if can stay injury free

Dayne Zorko - perfect bench cover as your F8 for the rest of the season

Toby Greene - depends on trades, if enough downgrade but if not can be reliable off the bench

Tomas Bugg - if he keeps his run with roles then no

Kyal Horsley - shown that he can be great M7 or even M6 at one point but his last two games have changed that

Jonathon Giles - definately a keeper, mature age so shouldnt slow down too much

Adam Treloar - if keeping zorko id trade him but if not can float between mids and forwards as your bench cover

Billie Smedts - not a keeper, end of story.

[DT Gun]

Back keepers average 80+
Midfield keepers average 100+
Ruck Keepers average 80+
Forward Keepers average 85+

[aces-high]

Back keepers average 80+
Midfield keepers average 100+
Ruck Keepers average 80+
Forward Keepers average 85+

+1
Well said. I think zorko is a keeper and will average 80+ and be my f7/8 along with treloar for the year! Giles has been great and is defs a keeper at r2 unless u have sufficient trades and can get ivaaaaaaan!! I think all the others are reliable bench options for the rest of the year and unless ur downgrading them should stay in ur team except smedts who is frustrating and should be traded to sam shaw if named this week :)