Main Menu

Hmac

Started by powersuperkents, June 12, 2012, 07:37:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Should he stay or should he got?

Trade him out
Hold Him

powersuperkents

Considering Holding on but a sideways trade to Goldstein looks tempting with his 31 BE

powersuperkents

Quote from: powersuperkents on June 12, 2012, 07:37:29 PM
Considering Holding on but a sideways trade to Goldstein looks tempting with his 31 BE
Or Patrick Ryder

Cam DM

I'm thinking of the big Sauce in, H-Mac out. Scores aren't usually huge, but 80 average for a player who basically holds up the ruck at the Crows and shouldn't be rested much. Plus price is good ATM.

powersuperkents

Quote from: Cam DM on June 13, 2012, 01:07:18 AM
I'm thinking of the big Sauce in, H-Mac out. Scores aren't usually huge, but 80 average for a player who basically holds up the ruck at the Crows and shouldn't be rested much. Plus price is good ATM.
Sam Jacobs looks like a gun his price has dropped aswell meaning he's most likely to rise

DT Gun

SO MANY PEOPLE JUMPING ON GOLDSTEIN!!!

Whhy the hell would you!

Yes he will score well for now but as soon as HMAC is back his scores go down the pisser and you burn another trade trying to patch another ruck mistake!

Windigo

It's a risk. But is the best ruck option aside from Cox or Maric.

Jacobs isn't worth it IMO.

henry

I'm holding. Will trade sandi for maric after his bye, and play giles/redden as 2nd ruck until h mac comes back. He will be back in around 6 weeks I believe and I am trying to conserve trades and in the meantime Giles should be good for 75s.

Tominator

Any idea when he is back?

I have Redden, Stephenson and Giles covering him, if two of them play til he comes back I'll be happy.

henry

Quote from: Tominator on June 13, 2012, 05:37:34 PM
Any idea when he is back?

I have Redden, Stephenson and Giles covering him, if two of them play til he comes back I'll be happy.
Listed in the injury list as 4-6 weeks I believ, but maybe add a week or two as he will probably play VFL first with goldy doing well without him meaning there is no rush to get him back. Barring any setbacks my guess would be ~7 weeks from now, hopefully less.

DT Gun

so you will get crap scores for the last 6 weeks

Tominator

oh wow. Should I trade if Redden and Stephenson get dropped? Got 1 extra cos I'm holding Pendles but with rucks dropping like flies I don't wanna make a FOURTH trade in that department this year..

Should I trade or hold?

Going for league not car

Holz

Quote from: DT Gun on June 13, 2012, 05:59:13 PM
so you will get crap scores for the last 6 weeks

thats under the assumption he will score really poorly with Hmac. Im thinkign he will still score godo with him back. I look at the strucutre and i can see them switching it up from what they had.,

DT Gun

It isnt assumption its fact.

He wont get 50 hit outs playing second fiddle

Ziplock

I dunno if he'll be playing second fiddle immediately considering hmacs injury, but fact is, if hmac is taking even 10-15 hit outs a game, that completely demolishes goldys scoring potential.

Colliwobblers

4-5 weeks all going well, could be longer and the roos can elevate majak daw so they very well might and get a few senior games into him this season and let hmac come back in through the seconds, so it could be 8, you have to trade if you can.