Stanton or Watson

Started by powersuperkents, June 12, 2012, 03:07:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should I bring in for Horsley this week/next week

Brent Stanton
Jobe Watson

powersuperkents

Stanton is more likely to score higher scores and lower scores, way more inconsistent and either unreliable or champion
Watson is way more consistent about to hit a price boom if he scores well again but hits the roof with a 130 score being his best

Stanton BE 161 at bargain price
Watson BE 93 gained $30k and set to hit a price boom

I'm edging towards Stanton because his DPP and MVP value

Torz


yorgis

stants can't handle a tag

FlipFlops

Yorgis is right, Stanton struggles with a tag and when tagged is likely to pull out 70s and 80s where as Jobe tends not to get tagged at all because it doesnt effect him.

Stanton is not a DPP either as someone has already said.

I've got both but if i had to choose one right now it'd be Jobe easily.

Ricochet

Stanton for higher ceiling
Watson for consistency

I'd be going Watson

dtrain

Stanton will get u 150's but will have off games were Watson will alway get ya 100's

fertalong

Bring in the 2012 brownlow medalist!

Jukes


HappyDEZ

I have Stanton & I would happily swap him for Jobe right about NOW if I could.

thanme

Yeah I picked up Stanton as a sideways for Swan. Should have gone Watson.

powersuperkents

Haha from this poll I have decided to go with Watson because that would balance the level of consistent to inconsistent players in my midfield. Also what is DDP I always though it had to do with potential or something?

My midfield if I trade in Watson is made up of:

Consistent:
Ablett (keeping), Watson (keeping), Ebert (keeping)
Inconsistent:
Hayes (planning to upgrade), Rockliff (keeping), Scott Selwood (undecided)

Spite

Quote from: fertalong on June 12, 2012, 03:35:33 PM
Bring in the 2012 brownlow medalist!

Why would you bring in an injured player? He is 2-3 weeks away from playing :P

chaosAD

Watson will ton up every week but when u need 140 in the last game on a sunday to win your league game, The STANTON WARRIOR is your man!

stew42

If cash is a worry, then Jobe is quite underpriced

Football Factory

Quote from: FlipFlops on June 12, 2012, 03:22:12 PM
Yorgis is right, Stanton struggles with a tag and when tagged is likely to pull out 70s and 80s where as Jobe tends not to get tagged at all because it doesnt effect him.

Stanton is not a DPP either as someone has already said.

I've got both but if i had to choose one right now it'd be Jobe easily.
Agree