who will be best at the end stanton vs watson

Started by gwsfevs, June 12, 2012, 02:36:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who will be the better player at the end of the year

stanton
7 (31.8%)
watson
15 (68.2%)

Total Members Voted: 2

gwsfevs

stanton pulls out higher scores watson more consistant

dtrain

Theres a similar post in trades forum Watson has the most votes

gwsfevs


Justin Bieber

Gws, you have posted quite a lot today.

At least these aren't +1's haha.

gwsfevs


Zombie2.5

Watson all the wayyy!!

Stanton will slow dowwn.
Even if he doesn't, I'd rather 100-120's every week instead of 70/150. Even then Stanton will get more 100's than 150's with the chance of 70 still. Captain Jobe!!

Fenno

Stanton for sure. If Stanton hadn't had an averag gameon the weekend the poll would look allot different. So many people on FF judge players on their last game

CrowsFan

Don't know if they're judging it solely on his last game. His last 3 he has averaged 95.67 with a high of 105, whereas Jobe has averaged 116.67.

Jobe has only had 2 scores below 100 (both in the 90's) for the season, whereas Stanton has had 4 (only 2 90's).

Watson is a much more consistent player, whereas Stanton will be a lot more up and down. He is capable of scoring much higher than Watson since he takes a lot more marks, but he also has a fair few off games still.

I would say Watson will have scored more come EOS

DT Gun

Watson will get injured and stanton will cop a hard tag while he is out and do nothing. I wouldnt pick either

Justin Bieber

Quote from: DT Gun on June 14, 2012, 01:53:33 AM
Watson will get injured and stanton will cop a hard tag while he is out and do nothing. I wouldnt pick either

I thought you said you don't want injury on players and the karma will get one of your players?

DT Gun

Its fact that Watson is quite injury prone and because he is tough trie to play through them.. Im not wishing it upon him, i just predict that he will at some stage

Fact - Watson has never played 22 games in a season
Fact - Stanton scores well when he gets loose ball and has never handled a tag

Justin Bieber

Watson has had 3 21 game seasons.

That makes him injury prone?

Windigo

Watson by a mile.

Put some $$$ on him for the Brownlow as well.  ;)

PowerBug

Quote from: CrowsFan on June 14, 2012, 01:52:22 AM
Don't know if they're judging it solely on his last game. His last 3 he has averaged 95.67 with a high of 105, whereas Jobe has averaged 116.67.

Jobe has only had 2 scores below 100 (both in the 90's) for the season, whereas Stanton has had 4 (only 2 90's).

Watson is a much more consistent player, whereas Stanton will be a lot more up and down. He is capable of scoring much higher than Watson since he takes a lot more marks, but he also has a fair few off games still.

I would say Watson will have scored more come EOS
And those two 90s were against GWS and GC. Essendon do not play those sides again for the rest of the year.

Chelskiman

Quote from: PowerBug on June 14, 2012, 03:58:47 PM
And those two 90s were against GWS and GC. Essendon do not play those sides again for the rest of the year.

Plus you would think, against those two, that he was only playing in 2nd gear.  I've had him from the start and he's easily been my most consistent player.