Sandy to who poll

[owenbond007]

pretty simple.

[Plastic Boy]

Despite Cox being the no-brainer, I'm thinking someone like Goldy.

Had his bye, Hmac still gone for a while and even when HMac is fit he'll have to come back via the two's.

and you can pocket some cash out of it

[Jukes]

I was going to go to Maric because he is the best ruck out there, but I'm going with Cox. Cox has already had his bye but Maric hasn't- and I'd rather have a good ruck combo of Cox/Giles then play Redden or Stephenson on the ground again- YUCK. And he's underpriced from his start price by a lot.

Go with Cox.

[owenbond007]

I already have maric was just making the poll more generalised for everybody in my boat. Not sure what Sandy BE is but pretty sure hell lose a bit of coin - but $$$ arnt a issue for me.

[Windigo]

Goldstein Vs Gold Coast=Gold Mine of points.  8)

[Andrew]

If you've got enough trades, now might be the best time to ditch Sandi. He's just too unreliable these days, even if he came back after his bye he's still no guarantee to play every game for the rest of the season.

Sandi -> Cox is my vote.

[owenbond007]

Goldstein Vs Gold Coast=Gold Mine of points.  8)

yeah but thats one game. what happens when hmac comes back?

[Windigo]

He is listed as 3-5 weeks last week.

Hopefully they err on the side of caution and they give him more time out.

Why rush him back when they arguably don't need a ruck when they have Goldy dominating?  ???

[owenbond007]

He is listed as 3-5 weeks last week.

Hopefully they err on the side of caution and they give him more time out.

Why rush him back when they arguably don't need a ruck when they have Goldy dominating?  ???

Do you think Goldy will be more productive than cox?

[Windigo]

His past 4 scores without H-Mac speak for themselves.

Natural progression suggests he should improve his average again in 2012.

However, the inclusion of H-Mac this year has destroyed any chance of that.

But 28 possessions a a ruck man is unbelievable.  ;)

In simple terms, Cox is the logical, safe and the 'boring' choice.

Goldy is a risk, but not that much. Last year he was a gun ruck for a reason.

[Football Factory]

Cox or Maric .. have 48k in the bank only want to use the one trade to fix this mess   :(

Maybe Jacobs if i cant afford the others  :'(

[henry]

Have sandi and hmac on my bench will be forced to play giles and redden next week. Hopefully they can combine for 60 points. I think I'll have to wait until maric has his bye and then get him in even if it means havjng a donut in round 13 when redden has the bye.

[samtheking]

Sandy is super coach gold when fit, i've got him in alongside ryder, giles and jenkins. However, Sandy has to go, way too unreliable, cox is the best choice with his price going down. Thoughts on a decent downgrade option for sandy to upgrade Giles later on?

[mufc]

how long is sandi out for havent had the time to look this up so i thought i'd throw the question out there

[Football Factory]

how long is sandi out for havent had the time to look this up so i thought i'd throw the question out there

Dont know yet waiting for scans and Freo to confirm what the injury actually is