Buddy Reported

[Colliwobblers]

the tackle was illegal, can you get out of that?

no injury and didnt put the guy over past his shoulder so it's a real minor one but it was still a sling tackle, i reckon a week, may have been a reprimand? if you can get a reprimand for a sling tackle? i think everyone who has done one has been given weeks for it, some may have had it reduced, but i'm also pretty sure buddy will have carry over points, not the most subtle tackler in the game...

[Football Factory]

the tackle was illegal, can you get out of that?

no injury and didnt put the guy over past his shoulder so it's a real minor one but it was still a sling tackle, i reckon a week, may have been a reprimand? if you can get a reprimand for a sling tackle? i think everyone who has done one has been given weeks for it, some may have had it reduced, but i'm also pretty sure buddy will have carry over points, not the most subtle tackler in the game...

I flowering hope so  :'(

[PowerBug]

I was at the game, i think he'll get done for his elbow to Hartlett's face. I can't remember any sling tackle.

[keffa]

Everyone has him, so if he misses, I'd say we'd all be impacted about the same?

Or not?

[Football Factory]

I was at the game, i think he'll get done for his elbow to Hartlett's face. I can't remember any sling tackle.

It looked like an elbow to the face .. thats what i thought at the time but after replays you can see it was actually his shoulder the impact jolts his head

[Colliwobblers]

Everyone has him, so if he misses, I'd say we'd all be impacted about the same?

Or not?

62.5% of every DT'er will be including me and every other comp i'm in

[Mr.Craig]

I was at the game, i think he'll get done for his elbow to Hartlett's face. I can't remember any sling tackle.

Were you out back having a beer PB? They replayed it on the big screen about 5 times! :P

I thought it looked pretty bad but having checked out the replay online I can't see him getting done for that. If it was a rough conduct charge (do they still even have those?) then I might be worried but the lack of head contact works in his favour.

Here's hoping. :-\

[PowerBug]

I was at the game, i think he'll get done for his elbow to Hartlett's face. I can't remember any sling tackle.

Were you out back having a beer PB? They replayed it on the big screen about 5 times! :P

Just saw it was in the 4th quarter. I left early into the 4th.

[Mr.Craig]

Just saw it was in the 4th quarter. I left early into the 4th.

Fair enough. :)

Power did alright considering. Good win for my boys though. :)

[PowerBug]

Just saw it was in the 4th quarter. I left early into the 4th.

Fair enough. :)

Power did alright considering. Good win for my boys though. :)

Yeah we did well. Although if we had Burgoyne Guerra and Clarkson back then we'd have won. :P

They are a top 8 side, port aren't, and it showed today. At least we weren't blown out of the park.

[Ziplock]

Selwood punched a bloke in the face and didn't get weeks for it. So it depends :P

[Mr.Craig]

Re - the first incident...

Me: I've seen kisses that made stronger contact.

Mate: You must watch some rough porn!

;D

[Tominator]

Selwood punched a bloke in the face and didn't get weeks for it. So it depends :P

Selwood is an umpire's pet - Buddy is the complete opposite!

[me]

does the person getting slung have to hit his head on the ground for the offending player to be rubbed out?

it's a huge sling, didn't hit his head, but looked pretty awkward on his shoulder/elbow - didn't really have the ball at any stage, it was quite dangerous

i dunno... mrp is so inconsistent

[Tominator]

does the person getting slung have to hit his head on the ground for the offending player to be rubbed out?

nobody knows these days......