Trade Suggestions (Reply for a cheer :) )

Started by Master Q, June 08, 2012, 07:17:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Master Q



Trade Suggestions? 65k. Copping 3 Donuts (Pre-Trades) in Scot, Tre (DPP) and Zorko (DPP). My Forward line needs work...

Thanks :)


Windigo

Not much you can do with the team as I see without wasting trades.  :-\




Kellogscrunchynut

Didak maybe, if he can hold onto current form.

Master Q

Sit and wait is what you guys are saying? What about upgrading/downgrading Tre and Zorko?

Colliwobblers

i am desperate to NOT trade scotland myself but without doing that i get 6.

I wouldnt do anything except possibly scotland - broughton or enright or johnson.

Clarke would have to go next week then. Furious about waters which was my clarke plan now has to be adcock.

trading horsley this round makes sense but will not save you a donut just put it off until 12 or 13 depending who you get.

treloar is close to cooked also, but trading him to a 12 or 13 player again just shifts the donut to that round.

Eat the donuts this round do upgrades over the next two rounds and you should have very few donuts in those two rounds.

*IF you have plenty of trades get rid of one of paine or walsh which are potentially dead wood and won't likely be playing to cover you in round 13 either.

*3 donuts this round seems well better than most too IMO

its me lads

Horsely out then zorko into mid and pick up premo fwd. Thats my 5 cents worth. Mind me asking how many trades you have left? You seem to have a selection of bad rookies :p

Windigo

Quote from: Colliwobblers on June 08, 2012, 07:25:18 PM
i am desperate to NOT trade scotland myself but without doing that i get 6.

I wouldnt do anything except possibly scotland - broughton or enright or johnson.

Clarke would have to go next week then. Furious about waters which was my clarke plan now has to be adcock.

trading horsley this round makes sense but will not save you a donut just put it off until 12 or 13 depending who you get.

treloar is close to cooked also, but trading him to a 12 or 13 player again just shifts the donut to that round.

Eat the donuts this round do upgrades over the next two rounds and you should have very few donuts in those two rounds.

*IF you have plenty of trades get rid of one of paine or walsh which are potentially dead wood and won't likely be playing to cover you in round 13 either.

*3 donuts this round seems well better than most too IMO

What he said. Too busy too go into depth. (Eating)  :P

Mr.Craig

Hampton to Elliott then Treloar to the best forward you can afford? :-\

I probably agree with Windy, you might have to just cop it on the chin.

Colliwobblers

Quote from: Master Q on June 08, 2012, 07:24:53 PM
Sit and wait is what you guys are saying? What about upgrading/downgrading Tre and Zorko?

Zorko i would keep forever - there will be lots of resting you need solid bench cover.

again trading either will just give you the donut in a later round. saves you nothing and neither of them are fully cooked yet, tho treloar is close.

trading treloar to a premium makes some sense you still get the donut for the bye the guy you trade in but you get an extra premium score this round. trading him to a rook makes little as you will likely score less with the replacement than what he will score and you still get a donut in the new players round....

Memphistopheles

Scotland to Broughton for me.

Also how much money do you have Q?


Justin Bieber

Wow you would be getting less donuts if you didn't have dud reverses like Paine and Walsh.

Chopps

if you do anything rookie to premo is the only way as you are still getting the donut but getting a premo score, as said above.

Master Q

Guys I have 12 Trades left. Do you guys think that is enough to make a Fwd bench luxury trade (or something else)?

The_Captain

Downgrace trealor. Upgrade horsley for Boyd/Thompson/rockliff/redden. Doesnt matter that they have the bye this week, you still need 2 guys on your bench and will work out perfect for bye structure.

turry17

I would wait, three seems to be less then most people are copping, including me  :'(
Maybe wait for Mitchell to be named then go Paine to him if trades allow??