Marley Williams

[natedoggy2233]

Opinions of downgrade from James Mcdonald to Marley Williams the the Horse to Watson

[Rowan1812]

No

[morelli89]

Williams doesn't have good JS, i don't think he will hold his spot when the pies get a few more guys back. so if you need him to be an emergency he's not a very good option IMO

[FlipFlops]

Don't like Marley's job security at all. Looking at Collingwood's team this week if Elliott, Seedsman and Ugle drop off the bench and Heater comes back say after the bye Marley's the obvious choice to make way for him. Hope i'm wrong because i also need to downgrade a mid rookie and he's the only obvious choice.

[Legen...DARY]

I'd probably look to Sexton mate. Not a huge scorer, but his JS is much better.
DPP too!

[Tominator]

is Sexton's JS really that good? I'm just not really sure on it. And if Williams is playing on a HBF think he'll need another injury  to somebody else (or just a blinder of a game) if he is to keep his spot when Heath Shaw comes back. Still thinking of getting him, need the cash, but I'm tempting fate here..

[Problems]

Trading in Marley Williams = very short term gain, mostly long term pain

[Legen...DARY]

is Sexton's JS really that good? I'm just not really sure on it. And if Williams is playing on a HBF think he'll need another injury  to somebody else (or just a blinder of a game) if he is to keep his spot when Heath Shaw comes back. Still thinking of getting him, need the cash, but I'm tempting fate here..

I wouldn't bet my swingers on it but IMO Sexton's JS is better than Marley's.  8)

[Windigo]

Same thing as Spurr. Everyone jumped on him and everyone said that J.Brennan had dodgy JS.

But Brennan has played every game since I think...

Who is to say he won't play significant game time this year.

[pinochio]

windy???

is it worth going like jmac/horse to elliot/williams/sexton??
will give me coverage as well as money??

13 trades and 77k left b4 trading this round

can go like horse/porps > sexton/williams (or elliot, but kinda risky imo) and have 11 trades left and a whopping 500k!!! lolz

thx hypes!

[Windigo]

windy???

is it worth going like jmac/horse to elliot/williams/sexton??
will give me coverage as well as money??

13 trades and 77k left b4 trading this round

thx hypes!

Hm, I reckon oust Horse & get Sexton. Maintains structure.

I think he should be okay for at least a couple of weeks. But you never know.

I got in Marley this week & Sexton last week.

[pinochio]

can go like horse/porps > sexton/williams (or elliot, but kinda risky imo) and have 11 trades left and a whopping 500k!!! lolz

its not too few trades???

is marley better then elliot?? you think?

[Windigo]

can go like horse/porps > sexton/williams (or elliot, but kinda risky imo) and have 11 trades left and a whopping 500k!!! lolz

its not too few trades???

is marley better then elliot?? you think?

I think 11 trades is pretty good.

getting marley is a huge risk. But your getting no where playing it safe. if you risk it and it fails well, you may go back wards.

but if your team is good enough then you will only need to play Marley on this field for the two bye weeks.

Elliot is in competition with Didak & Fasolo I'd think?

marley is a gun player in juniors averaging 21 possessions and was the pick (IMO) of the rookies for collingwood in terms of stats.

Ball & Pendles out of the mids may help.....

[pinochio]

very true windy - no guts no glory!!

trading porps is acceptable you think (along with horse)???

[Windigo]

Haven't been paying much attention to Porpz' scoring? been okay?  ???