Horse VS Jmac

[Shaddy94]

Pritty simmple^

Horse: high Be, Rested/ dropped questions about wether or not hes considered to be in the best 22 still. Bye doesnt effect my decision as i am tanking round 13 & going for league and dont care about this game

Jmac: High Be/ Rested requarly and is in and out of the side, Average decreasing age maybe catching up to him

I think although the horse is now "rested" and has a high b/e i think personally will be the better choice, as IMO he'll play more games and score more than Jmac

However want to here other opinions out there?

[Lozza]

i traded out both this week (to mitchell and williams) as horsley looks to have hit the wall and im not sure if mcdonald will increase to much over the next few weeks but if only one id get rid of horsley

[Plastic Boy]

i traded out both this week (to mitchell and williams) as horsley looks to have hit the wall and im not sure if mcdonald will increase to much over the next few weeks but if only one id get rid of horsley

I turned Horse into Ablett and Jmac into Cloke with a DPP move. Very happy with that

[Ricochet]

Are you looking at trading the other as well? or hanging onto as backup?
I would get rid of Horse this week only because he has a big BE now and likely to drop in price next time he plays.

[Shaddy94]

Are you looking at trading the other as well? or hanging onto as backup?
I would get rid of Horse this week only because he has a big BE now and likely to drop in price next time he plays.

Thinking of holding them for at least 4 weeks, till i can do my final mid upgrade. thats why i think horse will be the better long term keeper

[Slap]

Well Horse also has a bye in the next couple. Whereas JMAC doesn't and could be used for cover if needed.

to me that is the decision in a nutshell.  points on the field is valuable

Neither are playing this round so that remains a constant.

[Ricochet]

Well Horse also has a bye in the next couple. Whereas JMAC doesn't and could be used for cover if needed.

to me that is the decision in a nutshell.  points on the field is valuable

Neither are playing this round so that remains a constant.

exactly, and horse has a greater BE so there is potentially more money to be made out of Jmac

[Shaddy94]

Well Horse also has a bye in the next couple. Whereas JMAC doesn't and could be used for cover if needed.

to me that is the decision in a nutshell.  points on the field is valuable

Neither are playing this round so that remains a constant.

exactly, and horse has a greater BE so there is potentially more money to be made out of Jmac

Cheers lads you convinced me to get rid of the horse